My May submission results- Not too bad.

Ahmanfan

90475661 1961 TOPPS 150 WILLIE MAYS N/A 7
2 90475662 1949 BOWMAN 50 JACKIE ROBINSON N/A 1
3 90475663 1972 TOPPS 200 ROGER STAUBACH N/A 6
4 90475664 1967 TOPPS 569 A.L. ROOKIES R.CAREW/H.ALLEN 5
5 90475665 1955 TOPPS 123 SANDY KOUFAX N/A 1
6 90475666 1963 TOPPS 390 HANK AARON N/A Not Holdered, Evidence of Trimming
7 90475667 1972 TOPPS 150 TERRY BRADSHAW N/A 7


I was happy that the Koufax graded... you never know on those... Also was happy with the 5 not a 4 on the Carew.
The one that gets me is the Staubach, which looked to be a pretty solid 7 to me. The back was way OC, but I did not request NQ, so not sure how it got a 6...

Obviously I was disappointed with the '63 AAron, it wasn't even that nice... Looked 7ish to me... oh well that's how it goes. I'm pretty amazed that the Robinson and the Koufax could get the same grade... the Koufax had rounded corners and 2 creases, but the Robinson was dirty, had tape on it and was just a rough little card. Amazing how 2 cards so different can be lumped into 1 grade.
John

MajorDanby

thanks for the analysis. how did you attain these cards? I am assuming these are not for resale.

poolman

Nice cards! You're not questioning PSA graders are you?
The little Boo-Boo

Ahmanfan

Everything is for sale at a price. I wouldn't mind keeping the Robinson and Koufax RC's but everything else is available.

I attained the Mays and Carew in a local shop, the Koufax at a local show, the Robinson, Bradshaw, Staubach and AAron online.

JOhn