What to do?

Stingray

I received this 67 Gonder today and noticed it had a crack through the right hand corner. Did not see it in picture my fault for not seeing that. Though is was not in his description, but i noticed a guage (spelling) on the right side of the holder right on the seam, as though somone had tried to open it. The case does not appear to have been re-glued or anything and why bother with a common card as this. Before I leave a feedback I was just wondering what you thought. I have seen this seller a lot and think he is reputable.

Can not link up picture too big and do not want to link up auction has feedback link on it.


Stingray

SoFLPhillyFan

E-mail the pic to me, I'll post it.

soflphillyfan@comcast.net

BTW, your SMR will be mailed today.

Keith

SoFLPhillyFan

Here you go -

Stingray

Thanks, again the crack in the corner, I should have seen that! But I have never had a holder with what appears to be a guage on the seam? I e-mailed seller to see if he had noticed this?

Stingray

jrdolan

The crack and the gouge are unsettling, but the card looks like it could be an 8, a 7 at the very worst. I can't imagine someone troubling to crack a Jesse Gonder 8 out of its holder in order to put a Jesse Gonder 7 in its place. If it's just a poor job of slabbing, or it's merely incidental damage, PSA will re-slab it for you for $5. The only thing is they charge ungodly amounts for shipping a single card, and they won't let you include this on the same submission sheet with other types of service.

Stingray

That a possibility, would I have to be member? I am not questioning the grade of the card, I just have never had a holder that had these types of issues. Like you said I was a little unsettled seeing that on a holder and wonder myself why on a card as this. I could scan in the side but you would not be able to see what I am talking about on the gauged part of it.

Stingray

PS I left the seller a positive and only stated "fast shipment", which it was.