which looks better (52 bowman mays)

BigtimeBowmanfan

I am looking to pick up a 52 may's. Which one do you guy's like ? I must admit that i am very happy buying GAI cards but feel that on the vintage stuff they are much harsher on there grade's than PSA. Just my opinion but i think these auctions show a pretty good example. Unless i am missing something from one auction scan to another.

link 1

link 2

link 3

oaktown

Link 2 and 3 are of the same PSA card. But judging from the GAI v. PSA, I'd say the GAI has more eye appeal.

BigtimeBowmanfan

Oops.........sorry, heres the correct one.

revised link 3

Stingray

I would say the GAI one the centering is the best on this one, corners are better the other ones IMO.

Stingray

Stingray

Well now, I think that link #3 looks the best.


Stingray

stown

I would say 3,1, and 2.

Reason I put 2 last is because of the bottom right hand corner

oaktown

<< <i>I would say 3,1, and 2. >>



agreed.

BigtimeBowmanfan

Wow, i thought that the first link would get the vote. Now i have to reasses which to go with. oh well there are worse things to be doing.

SDSportsFan

I like #3 best, then #1 and #2 last.


Steve

Stingray

<< <i>Wow, i thought that the first link would get the vote. Now i have to reasses which to go with. oh well there are worse things to be doing. >>



Do you mean "two reasses" and who were you refering to?

Stingray

WinPitcher

If card 1 has a stain free reverse it is as nice as 3. 2 is to be avoided.

however with that said I would go with the 3 1 2 tally.

check and see if card 1 has a clean back.

Steve

edited to add card 1 description claims a clean reverse. I want to hear "stain free" ...............

Knuckles

#3, #2 then #1 for me.. that gai one looks like a$s