Really Good Grading Question. What if a Crossover Coin Has Hidden Damage?

markglicker

Hypothetical. Lets say that a collector submits a slabbed Morgan for crossover grading. The grader agrees to cross. When the coin is removed from the original holder, significant damage is noted on the reeding. The grader cannot reseal the coin in the submitted holder, but if he bodybags the coin, the collector takes a bath.

RYK

Good question for the Q&A with DH. I am sure it has happenned on more than one occasion.

PutTogether

What would happen? I'd get pissed. Almost "someone just slept with my wife" pissed.


Edited to add: That is a PERFECT question for the Q and A.

markglicker

Thanks, I Think I will address it to Mr. Hall.

GAT

As we use to say in the Air Force, your SOL!

relayer

I would assume once it's cracked, it has been graded by PCGS and falls under their warranty.

You crack it - you bought it