Would you trust this card?

eadams24

Mathews

Kityoung cards is the seller. Isn't there some relationship between them and Alan Rosen, aka Mr. Mint?

Lodi

A feedback of almost 9000 with a 99.9% rating. If you can't trust him who could you trust?

From the listing:
If ever you receive something that is unsatisfactory, you may return it for replacement or full refund.

lostdart58

KITYOUNG is one of the GIANTS of card sellers................but BARGAIN is not in their vocabulary.

ajw

Wow. Check out what Kit Young has up for sale. Ruth, Gehrig, Mantle and more

Whoa. The last card he has for sale is graded by FGS. Who's FGS? Why would such a prominent dealer have a FGS card?

rainmaker

Auction says "Finest Grading Services"

I've never heard of them before. With a BIN of $9.95 why are they even bothering to list it....

jrdolan

<< <i>Why would such a prominent dealer have a FGS card? >>


Well, cards in FGS holders have often been rejected or given a lower grade by PSA, SGC, GAI. But I didn't think Kit Young was playing that game. He's the king of overpriced, low-grade, raw cards. You'd think he'd just sell it raw.

rainmaker

I'm surprised that most of those cards aren't slabbed. Those Gehrig and Ruth cards would look nice in a PSA holder and then the buyer would know what they are getting....

packCollector

]

<< <i>I'm surprised that most of those cards aren't slabbed. Those Gehrig and Ruth cards would look nice in a PSA holder and then the buyer would know what they are getting.... >>



but then he couldn't call this card vg-vg/ex

[

RipublicaninMass

Where is Winpitcher on this thread? I am sure he would have a comment or two eh?

NickM

Kit Young buys entire collections, Mr. Mint flips a lot of cards to him. I'm quite certain that any FGS card in Young's possession was part of a lot purchase.

I don't think he's a card doctor. I do think his grading is not comparable with PSA's standards.

Nick