I need NGC help

badger · March 15, 2005 2:21PM

Buy the coin not the holder right?? I have the following in NGC:

1951 5c PR67DCam
1958 1c PR68Dcam
1958 1c PR69Dcam
1961 1c PR69Dcam

These are gorgeous coins. Super contrast. Deeep mirrors. But, NGC coins that don't go into the registry.

I am torn about sending these to auction or keeping them because they are very nice coins with super eye appeal.

Comments welcome prior to sending these to Heritage.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 2:23PM

what kind of help?

solid · March 15, 2005 2:24PM

Numismatic
Guaranty
Corporation

Does that help?

Ken

badger · March 15, 2005 2:28PM

It's 1:30 a.m. here so excuuuuuse me for hitting 'enter' before it's time.

Check the revision, por favor.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 2:35PM

If you like them keep them but if you want to sell them you have a payday ahead.Besides they are modern crap anyway

solid · March 15, 2005 2:36PM

Oh sure, fix your post and now make mine look silly!

If you want them in a PCGS Registry set, what about trying to cross them?

Or, just keep them as premium coins - no crime there!

Do you have a photo of the nickel?

Ken

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 2:36PM

You could send them to ICG then give them to me

badger · March 15, 2005 2:42PM

I really appreciate all the help

I will get pic of the Jeff and post. I have responded to some PM's offering guidance.

Solid: Be aware that I know how to correct posts.

Dave

Kurt4 · March 15, 2005 2:49PM

"These are gorgeous coins"--Quote by you. Keep 'em. I think NGC is solid on these dates. I don't think the cross potential is worth it.

relayer · March 15, 2005 2:50PM

If they don't go into the Registry then it would be silly to keep them.

Kurt4 · March 15, 2005 2:52PM

Relayer---------Good point!

badger · March 15, 2005 2:55PM

Midwestcoin:

I don't gamble with ICG anymore.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 2:56PM

<< Midwestcoin:

I don't gamble with ICG anymore. >>

Fine but if you need extra money read my sigline coustomer

badger · March 15, 2005 3:00PM

Midwestcoin -

Coustomer is French right? Are you French? I don't deal with no Frogs.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:02PM

<< Midwestcoin -

Coustomer is French right? Are you French? I don't deal with no Frogs. >>

not french and I have no idea if it's french.Now sell your kidney!

badger · March 15, 2005 3:05PM

Lord M:

Help me out here. Coustomer is French, right??

Regardless, I have tried some ICG Pr69 Jeffs. These seem to cross at Pr66. I will admit I do not have a statistical sampling.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:06PM

<< Lord M:

Help me out here. Coustomer is French, right??

Regardless, I have tried some ICG Pr69 Jeffs. These seem to cross at Pr66. I will admit I do not have a statistical sampling. >>

lesson one with ICG beware of the moderns.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:06PM

You should still look at ICG though.

badger · March 15, 2005 3:08PM

Midwestcoin: I defer to your seniority. 990 posts vs. 425.

Just bellyaching about the difference in grading approach between PCGS and NGC.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:10PM

<< Midwestcoin: I defer to your seniority. 990 posts vs. 425. >>

I spend a lot of time in the OF so you probably have posted ore good onfo then me.

badger · March 15, 2005 3:10PM

Midwestcoin,

Saw your latest post....

I have convinced myself that MODERNS start at 1964. Maybe this is dilusional.

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:13PM

<< Midwestcoin,

Saw your latest post....

I have convinced myself that MODERNS start at 1964. Maybe this is dilusional. >>

not dilusional it's true.

badger · March 15, 2005 3:15PM

Continued from last thread::

To diversify, I have assumed Moderns start at 1950 and have started collecting prewar cameo proofs. Major announcement to those reading the thread: "Prewar cameos are HOT".

midwestcoin13 · March 15, 2005 3:18PM

<< Continued from last thread::

To diversify, I have assumed Moderns start at 1950 and have started collecting prewar cameo proofs. Major announcement to those reading the thread: "Prewar cameos are HOT". >>

I dont know why they would start at 1950 because 1964 sounds the most reasonable.

michael · March 15, 2005 3:19PM

keep them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

and start your own registry set on your own web site or aq web host where you can show off each coin in a photo and describe it

and believe you me if they are as great as you say they are and i have no doubt in my mind that they are

if you are a long time collector i bet within 5/10 years the only thing that will matter will be the coins

good luck

and collect only the best coins you like in any holders as long as the coin is all there and with discretionary income

badger · March 15, 2005 3:24PM

Michael,
Thanks for the comments. I hear you saying the coins are the thing not the holder. Be in the coins for the long term if the quality is there.

Dave

Editted to include: Use discretionary income with the collecting. Good guidance

michael · March 15, 2005 3:36PM

dave i have no doubt you got killer coins

the coins will sell themselves if they are all there

in fact i would rather have a great killer monster coin that is all there and then some in an ngc holder

as i can get it at a better value from an unknowledgable seller

michael · March 15, 2005 3:38PM

and if you look at a coin in an ngc or pcgs holder ...................

ask yourself this question

would i be comfortable to cracking this coin out of its holder???

if the answer is NO then the coin is not for you

michael · March 15, 2005 3:45PM

or better yet if you look at a pcgs or ngc coin

and if it was broken out of the holder and it is worth less than 70% of its selling value when it was in the holder

then LET THE BUYER BEWARE

MrSpud · March 15, 2005 7:51PM

Just start another Registry set over at NGC. They let you use both NGC and PCGS coins so you could just take an existing PCGS Registry et and also register the same coins plus the NGC ones.

fivecents · March 15, 2005 8:45PM

You can always bite the bullet and spend $18 per coin to try to cross them to PCGS.

I need NGC help

Comments

Leave a Comment