Please grade the 1928 Peace $ rev added

papabear

Your opinion Please


Thank You Papabear

Reverse added

TonedPeaceNut

AU53 -- just on the obverse. -- Actually now comparing the 3 -- I'll go AU50 based upon the hair definition.

Here's an ANACs AU53 for comparison



And a ANACs AU50




TPN

mr1931S

Looks like has been cleaned to me but impossible to say for sure from image. No reverse image provided, so my opinion of grade from looking at obverse wear is that the coin might be about EF40 but would net grade lower depending on the harshness of any cleaning that may have occurred. Doesn't appear to have any original mint luster to me so I rule out any of the AU grade numbers for this coin.

jdimmick

The luster looks gone for an AU coin, maybe Xf-45. This is a tough coin to grade from PIC's alone.


jim

TheRaven

I thought a high XF, but I hate grading this series.

A nice coin never the less.

mgoodm3

i like the high EF theory.

ms70

40

PutTogether

Not going to wager a guess on the cleaning issue, tough from the picture. But its EF 40-45 technical grade.

nwcs

Looks like AU details to me.

prooflike

I'll say the xf45, maybe au

papabear

added reverse image

FatMan

AU details, but if the image is accurate it looks dipped out or harshly cleaned. Not a bit of luster remains.

RickMilauskas

Looks like an XF 45 to me. The hair where the ear would be is too worn to make AU in my opinion.
Also the scarcity of lustre makes me think it looks XF not AU.

Shamika

AU-50

Inditonka

AU53 to me.

fivecents

AU53

coinbuf

I agree with what has been said, no luster shows in your pics so I'd say XF45. If in hand there is some luster then AU50

Chris

PutTogether

I'm TTTing this in hopes people read all the different grades. It proves two points.........Peace dollars are tough to grade, and it's not so much the GRADE that matters, but what a coin looks like.