Poll: U Grade it - ANSWER REVEALED

wybrit

Rims cut out so that the slab type is not identifiable.

JamminJ

Is the chatter on the cheek & veil strike weakness?

-JamminJ

coinkat

Wybrit:

I voted MS62 in light of the obverse ticks. The coin has nice lustre and the reverse is attractive, but it is a small coin and the small ticks seem alittle overwhelming for a coin this size. I am willing to concede that the photo and it size may enhance the ticks and marks and in reality, they may not be as pronounced as in the picture.

Aethelred

I also voted MS-62, but let it be said I am grading the photo not the coin.

lordmarcovan

61 on technicality. Nice eye appeal for a 61, though.

ajaan

NGC MS62

MacCrimmon

Image looks to be MS62.

ccrdragon

where's the 'send the POS to me' option ?!?!?!?!? (j/k)

I voted 62 as well because of the chatter.

drjules

Hey I must have learnt something from all these "grade it" threads as I said MS62 as well

theboz11

I gave it a 60 because of the chatter.(Not that I have any idea how to grade these)

MSD61

NCG MS61 for the same reasons as others have stated....... because of the chatter.

But hey who knows? We see coins one way and the Demi-gods of grading see it another I am of the opinion anymore when it comes to grading that what we think is bad the big wigs say is good and what we think is good the big-wigs say it's bad

Luvdawgs

I also said MS62 for the reasons given above.

wybrit

It's not one of my better pictures.

I'll have to have another look at it, but right now it's in lockup.

Actual slab grade: PCGS MS64.

Unless the image picked up some artifact (and that has happened to me on occasion), I would say it's a bit overgraded.

JamminJ

<< <i>Actual slab grade: PCGS MS64. >>





-JamminJ

WhiteLighnin

I guess MS-64......

spinaker2000

I gave it a 60.

farthing

64 with all those marks - wow!

I voted 61 BTW

MyWorldCoinTypeSet

I picked 63 - with the exception of the hit behind the mouth, the other marks seem minor.

Askari

Frankly, I gave it a MS60 ... perhaps I grade more conservatively than PCGS. While the underlying coin is very nice and I could see it getting 64 without all that chatter, somehow letting the chickens peck feed off it that much doesn't let me feel too good about allowing it anything above 62.