Sending back a toned Morgan for rev out holdering..Is it worth it?

Trooper

Recieved my 4 coin freebie order today and noticed one of the coins, which I made note of on the 2x2 to holder "rev forward" was holdered normaly. This coin is has a nice toned reverse. I talked to customer service and they said to send it back and it will be taken care of.

Is it worth sending back? The date is common '84 O and the grade is a ms63.
Would you as a buyer prefer the rev out if it has a nice tone or it wouldn't matter.
Thanks
Tom

Tonekiller

If you want it then its worth it. Thats a nice toner!

TBT

kryptonitecomics

I personally don't care for reverse holdered coins....I can easily flip it to see both sides so for me...I voted no it's not worth it.

ddbird

I would call PCGS and demand a free grading but keep that one the way it is. I dont like reverse holdering...I think the obverse should be seen first even if its not as pretty.

XpipedreamR

Reverse holdering is annoying.

kieferscoins

<< <i>Reverse holdering is annoying. >>



Not in every instance. State quarters I like the reverse showing the state side out. PCGS didn't do this in 1999.

Cameron Kiefer

JrGMan2004

Pretty one-sided toners, I like Reverse out

etexmike

I like the best side out no matter which side that is.

Do it.

-----------

etexmike

ArtR

<< <i>Pretty one-sided toners, I like Reverse out >>


Me Too.

mgoodm3

Nice toning. go for it.

uofa1285

will they pay for your additional s/i since it was their error?

pharmer

When I see a reverse out, it says to me that there is something special about the reverse. I would do it in this case.

ER

If it bugs you, send it back.

Stuart

I personally prefer not to have coins reverse-side-up holdered -- But if you prefer it that way send it back to make you happy.