Got some nice grades
techeff
Posts: 2,285
1910: I thought it had a shot at 64, but I'll take it.
1882: OK
1926: Cracked out of an NGC63 holder.
1917: This lady's been around: PCGS64, NGC64, ANACS64 and finally where she belongs. I knew she could do it. And nicely toned to boot.
0
Comments
-----------
etexmike
You mention it had been through the big3 all at MS64.
You also mention it is nicely toned....
Do you think that all the graders could have been right at MS64 and that the toning is hiding something now? Or that the toning gave it a little bump?
Note: It doesn't matter to me either way, I've never seen the coin, and I don't collect WL halves, but I am curious about that.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
Bochi, The coin is virtually mark free and the toning isn't hiding anything. I believe it's been conservatively graded in the past because the strike is "a little" weak in the center of the coin. I would grade it 64.7 and honestly I just wanted to get it back in a PCGS holder and be done with it. I guess I got a gift.
Bravo, well done! Can you post some images whenever? I'd like to see the 1926.