Opinions Requested - 1928 Peace and 1872 Seated Dollars

itsnotjustme

Hey folks, my brother and his wife came across these two in a collection from her mother's estate. He and I would like to hear opinions on the condition. I have mine but I am by no means a Peace or Seated expert.

Photos at this link.

Photos

construct

I'd call the Peace Dollar an AU-50 cleaned. The Seated Dollar I'd call an EF-40.

coinguy1

The Seated Dollar looks like a nice XF coin. The Peace Dollar appears to be a lightly cleaned, high grade AU example.

TommyType

How are we going to have any good fights if we all agree with each other?

What they said.

itsnotjustme

ttt

coinkat

The 1872 is EF45 OR EVEN AU50. I like it. The 28 Peace Dollar is a dog because it was hairlined by a cleaning. It is a BB candidate and would be net graded by ANACS. Sorry, but I am just calling it the way I see it.

BigGreek

The 1928 is AU-53 but may have too many hairlines for a grade at PCGS, the 1872 is EF-40,
also cleaned but not as harshly.

Hedger

Unfortunately, both are cleaned. Nice coins but cleaned. Luster on both too shiny.

coinkat

The 1872 looks better than the 1928...