NGC * STAR Coins

jamesfsm

Given the current state of the arms race between PCGS and NGC, would you rather have the same, identical toned Morgan (monster) in NGC MS65* or PCGS MS65? Why? Remember: the coin is the same, only the slab differs.

airplanenut

I'd rather see the two and choose. The star can have meaning, but the ultimate judge of eye appeal is the buyer.

Jeremy

BigD5

I'd take the 65* over the pcgs 65. I think this one would be split 50/50 between both choices.

paigowjohnny

I agree with the nut !!

IrishMike

Coins are never the same. I'd take the * if it looks better and vice versa.

thebeav

I would take the star....The perception that appears to surround it would get me a better price at sale time....

Paul

klorineforbrains

I think the question was meant to be like this:
if you had a moster toned morgan, would you want it in a ngc 65*, or in a pcgs 65?

TONEDDOLLARS

If the coin is the same in whichever slab, I would not care if it was in a ICG, PCI, ANACS, or even Accugrade. But thats just me.