Home Trading Cards & Memorabilia Forum

old collector returning to the hobby

After buying my first house, my mother informed me that i could take all my football and baseball cards home with me. After flipping through them (and remember seeing some of them for the first time), I've been bitten by the collecting bug. When I last collected, Upper Deck had just come on the scene. I bought a Beckett to see what some of my cards might be worth, and noticed all the new companies.

My question is: with all the card companies out there today, which card lines (for football and baseball) should a new collector be looking at, and which ones to avoid? Which card lines hold their value the best? Which card lines give you the most value (purchase price vs. resale value?)

Norseman

Comments

  • Welcome, your story sounds very much like mine I also am a Vikings fan (also big 49ers fan but being from only 35 miles from the dome I get to see the Vikings weekly on TV so they are my slight favorite) I'm in the process of getting all my cards to my new house.

    As for your questions I would either just focus on what you like for fun or if some any type of investment go with vintage stuff as theres just tons of everything being made today and back to the early 80s which makes it not worth much at all. I know I probably have 75,000 or so cards I spent probably $6-8k on back in late 80s to early 90s and now they are almost all worth nothing especially since none are graded, if I did grade my better items (some Rice/Montana/Young/Sanders/Smith/ect rookies for football and Puckett/Clemens/McGwire/Griffey/ect rookies for baseball and other assorted stuff) and they got 8s ( i know not to expect 9s or 10s) I could maybe get a grand or so but probably won't go that route will just sell/trade so stuff raw for what I want to collect now mostly for fun.
  • hmm why no warm welcome for this new guy? maybe because he posted in evening so I'll bump it for the morning/day people image
  • Welcome Norse,

    I'm pretty new myself but I think you'll find that there are a lot of helpful and friendly people on these boards that share the same passion for collecting that you do. I recently returned to the hobby as well and the last thing I remember from collecting was also upper deck. Cards have changed a bit since those good old days... now you've got to deal with serial numbers, autographs, game used memorabilia... and last but not least, grading. I think that you should basically collect whatever you like. I'm not really into all of that stuff I listed above, except for grading, I'd rather just buy the base cheap cards of my favorite players rather than paying a premium on some gimics. The best part about this is that I can usually get my favorite cards of favorite players in Gem Mint form for the same cost or a little more than it would cost me to send it into PSA. Since returning to the hobby I've picked up an 89 Donruss Gary Sheffield ($10), 90 Topps Traded Emmitt Smith ($10) and an 89 Topps Traded Deion Sanders ($6) all PSA 10! I really like the benefits of grading as you know the quality of card you are getting and I also feel it helps protect the value of the cards should you ever need to resell them. Some new football sets I like are 2004 Topps Football and 2004 Fleer Tradition. They are base sets but have some pretty cool looking cards. The Fleer Tradition set has a couple cool "Trio" cards, one which shows E. Manning/P. Rivers/B. Roethlisberger and another that shows Ro. Williams/Re. Williams/L. Fitzgerald. Anyways, welcome back to the community and I hope that you find eBay and PSA will make the hobby more enjoyable for you.
  • image
  • My recommendation is to collect the cards that most appeal to you!

    image
  • Welcome to the boards Norse. As you probably have figured out, there is a ton of product out there right now. Enjoy the choices available to you. You can collect modern sets with all the Hi-gloss "bells and whistles". You can collect autographs, game-used cards. There are sets with a vintage look. There are sets (like Upper Deck Legends) that incorporate older/retired players with todays modern players.
    Bottom line, collect what you like and you can never go wrong.image
    Baseball is my Pastime, Football is my Passion
  • Thanks to everyone that replied. I've noticed from reading postings on this site that everyone seems to be very easy to talk too, and very informative. I've picked up a few things from this site in just a couple weeks.

    Thanks again
    Norseman
  • Yes you are right I am new to this saite myself and easily the first week I picked up a ton of diferent things. And the things that I did not know I asked and I got an immediate answer. It was great, have you signed up with PSA or another company yet. What are you collecting and specifics?
  • No, I haven't signed up with PSA yet. I haven't decided what to send to get graded. The first cards I collected are in tough shape ( due to alot of enjoyment and use as a child). I do have a rookie Marino and Elway that I have thought about sending in, but I'm not sure how they will grade. I'm pretty sure my rookie Montana won't make a PSA8, so I don't know if I should send that in either.

    One thing I was wondering. When a card is sold and shipped in the mail, how should it be packaged to avoid any damage?

    Norseman
  • jUST WHEN YOU THOUGHT YOU WERE OUT, THEY PULL YOU BACK IN! DAMN THOSE CARDS!







    << <i>After buying my first house, my mother informed me that i could take all my football and baseball cards home with me. After flipping through them (and remember seeing some of them for the first time), I've been bitten by the collecting bug. When I last collected, Upper Deck had just come on the scene. I bought a Beckett to see what some of my cards might be worth, and noticed all the new companies.

    My question is: with all the card companies out there today, which card lines (for football and baseball) should a new collector be looking at, and which ones to avoid? Which card lines hold their value the best? Which card lines give you the most value (purchase price vs. resale value?)

    Norseman >>



  • << <i>One thing I was wondering. When a card is sold and shipped in the mail, how should it be packaged to avoid any damage? >>

    Welcome Norseman! Make sure you explore the PSA website; there is lots of good information on there. The answer to your question is here.
Sign In or Register to comment.