Old Judge pasted in book - graded AUTHENTIC or PSA 1?

mariotown

I sent in an Old Judge I suspect was pasted in a book and then cut out. I requested it be labeled AUTHENTIC if it couldn't be assigned a grade. Is your experience that they honor such requests? Also, what constitutes the reasoning behind encapsulating as a PSA 1 versus AUTHENTIC? Why would trimmed tobacco cards not be encapsulated as AUTHENTIC?

Kevin

cozmokramer

PSA does in fact encapsulate Old Judges as authentic when trimmed. You do however have to request it when submitting.

lsutigers1973

Why are you searching the forum for old threads?