Pilgrim and Texas Comm Questions

LeeG

Found these running around different sites on the net. The 1920 Pilgrim is a Raw coin. The seller listed it for $300. I sent him an email with some pricing for this coin in different grades and he did come down to $265 I feel that's still way too high for a raw coin. Yes it has a good strike and nice color but have I have no clue as to the grade. Can I get some help on the grade. MS65 prices on Heritage range from $288-$340, without color. In 64 they drop to $104-$115, without color. The Texas is a NGC 65 holder for $175. That seems about right based on Heritage prices realized, without color. Can I get some thoughts on these. Appreciate It!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Lee

astrorat

If you have no clue on the grade of the Pilgrim, then why are you even considering the coin . . . regardless of price?

Lane

keets

buy the Texas and say thanks but no thanks on the Pilgrim.

al h.

LeeG

Ok Lane. Let me rephrase. I have an approximate range of where this coin grades at. I'm far from a grading expert. I've been burnt in the past so I like to get other more knowledgeable opinions than mine. Is that a crime? I like the look of the coin so I wanted to get some opinions on it. It's that simple. Thanks for asking! Thanks Al for the positive comments!!!!!! Lee

tcmitssr

<< <i>buy the Texas and say thanks but no thanks on the Pilgrim.

al h. >>



What he said!