Has anyone sent in for review and had it come back higher? +my 2nd submission
JERO
Posts: 68 ✭
A new forum for a question I ran across in another thread... 1. Has anyone EVER sent a card in to PSA in its holder for review and have it come back a HIGHER grade? I find this to be very, very, very unlikely. If it happens, then PSA is essentially saying "yea, we mess up"
Another note, I sent in my second submission after really looking into my graded 38 Goudeys trying to get a feel for what PSA grades. All 38 Goudeys...
Predicted 5 got a 4.
Predicted 3 got a 3.
Predicted 2 got a 3.
Predicted 5 got a 4.
Predicted 6 got a 7 (!!). Pop 6, only 6 higher all 8s (!!!!!)
Predicted 4 got a 4.
Overall I feel like i'm getting there. Feel much better after my first 38 (looks like a 6) came back a 2 because I didn't see the 1/16th inch border tear.
JERO
Another note, I sent in my second submission after really looking into my graded 38 Goudeys trying to get a feel for what PSA grades. All 38 Goudeys...
Predicted 5 got a 4.
Predicted 3 got a 3.
Predicted 2 got a 3.
Predicted 5 got a 4.
Predicted 6 got a 7 (!!). Pop 6, only 6 higher all 8s (!!!!!)
Predicted 4 got a 4.
Overall I feel like i'm getting there. Feel much better after my first 38 (looks like a 6) came back a 2 because I didn't see the 1/16th inch border tear.
JERO
0