Quick grading question...

ddbird

What does the holder say, and what should it grade?
Obverse


Reverse


Thanks!

nwcs

Holder says 65. Can't say what the coin looks in hand.

ddbird

Hmm...is that what that other 65 means...

ER

64PL

DennisH

65 and 65

tjkillian

You forgot to hide the number past the "." in the coin number. That number tells us it is a 65.

Tom

ddbird

boo thats what I thought...It is a 65, but I think its purrdy one. Its got a BIN for 130...think its worth it?

ibzman350

greysheet dated 09/10/04=$135



Herb

itsnotjustme

Clearly a 65... your forgot to line out ALL the critical info on the holder.

itsnotjustme

It does have a PL look to the obverse. The reverse might be hidden in toning.

Russ

<< <i>Hmm...is that what that other 65 means... >>





Russ, NCNE

UncleJoe

How about this 1881-S? and don't forget to read the auction.

1881-S

Joe.

DRUNNER

Like everyone has previously mentioned . . . 65.

I think it is always tough to say what a coin is really like unless you can examine it in person . . . i.e. the sometimes minute differences between a 64.9 and a 65.1 are too tough to tell from a scan. This could even be a 66 (old holder) if viewed in person . . or a coffin 64.

DRUNNER

MORGANHUNTER2

Uncle Joe: Do you think the seller has it in for the la familia- I read his ad- holy coin sale Batman- ah-collectibles may be trying to scam gotham city once again!