How would you grade this one?

gemini12398

Would appreciate your expert opinions, ladies and gents...Also could NCS do something with this toning?

airplanenut

Depends on the lustre... can't see marks, but probably 63/64. I doubt that toning could be dipped off successfully...

ziggy29

Can't grade the coin without a reverse, but I'd guess AU-58 based on what I see (unless it's just a flat strike, in which case, perhaps MS-63). I doubt it's worth conserving even if one thought it could be improved by doing so.

gemini12398

Here is the reverse...

DennisH

MS63

ColonialCoinUnion

I'd say 63 or 64. I would bet it grades higher and sells for more after a dip - though it pains me to say that.

gemini12398

turns out it was a 64 in a first generation holder. I thought it might have more meat on it, but you guys were dead on...

Thanks all,

David

nankraut

I like the color