Which of These Toned Dollars Would Bring More Money on Ebay?

dragon

The one in the Capital holder is actually more vibrant and flashy, but the pics are both poor.

robertpr

Duh, the holdered one. It has been "legitimized" by the grading service.

Plus, it's an older slab.

FC57Coins

Even though it has more chatter on the face, I think the colors on #1 are more appealing and vibrant to me - so I'd go with that one.

kryptonitecomics

I like the toning on the 2nd coin better, but I agree that the holdered coin would sell for more. I don't think anyone would question the authenticity of the toning on the 2nd coin, just maybe whatever grade you assigned.

tradedollarnut

The first one.

morgannut2

As is, the first coin is worth exactly $15 plus mailing costs more. Once in a holder, to my eye the 84 is worth about $20-40 more due to the toning pattern at a minimum ( plus color is a bit rarer on an '84, and bit nicer cheek).

coinbuf

Hmmm toined coin and ebay, you should be able to pay your house in full if you sell either one.

Chris

LincolnCentMan

My estimate for coin #1 $200-$220
My estimate for coin #2 $140-$180

David

Coinhusker1

What if the raw one is an 1884-S?

morgannut2

Oh 1884-s! Well you always just put a 2 in front of the other prices. Simple!

Hadleydog

If both coins are common date, the NGC piece.
Of course, if the 'authenticated' piece was in a trash holder (ntc, accugrade), I would go with the raw piece!

bestclser1

NGC64 WOULD BRING 350+