Grades - Got killed...arrg

clackamas

1 21773439 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773440 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773436 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773437 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773438 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773433 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773434 1958 1C USA MS66RD
1 21773435 1958 1C USA MS66RD
2 21773441 1957 10C USA MS66FB

tmot99

Think of it this way... You are the proud owner of 8 fairly average red pennies and one nice dime.

cdan12

what were you expecting on the grades?

Gonfunko

Hoping for 67's? Doesn't look that bad - no BB's.

MadMarty

after my bout with PR68DCAMs all I can say is "I feel your pain!"

clackamas

<< <i>what were you expecting on the grades? >>



I set up 3 of the 58-P's for 67RD and the dime was so nice it should have been a 67FB. It is nicer than 3 of the MS67's I own.

jacktheknife

Doesn't bode well for me. I have just cracked out 2 NGC Lincolns worth about $5000 and 5 pcgs Lincolns that I thought were undergraded. Maybe I should wait to send them in.

Jack

haletj

Sorry clackamas. Don't sell those should be ms67 coins. You may just have to wait. PCGS is being ridiculous when it comes to getting ms67's right now. I should have an ms67 70-s,80-d and maybe even a 64-d.

lava

Lots of red.

What was the turn-around time?

dorkkarl

good grief, how much $$$ did you flush on that submission? this is'nt some kind of trick-or-treat joke, is it???

K S

clackamas

<< <i>good grief, how much $$$ did you flush on that submission? this is'nt some kind of trick-or-treat joke, is it???
K S >>



Well Karl, since you would never have sent any of these coins in and the 57 66FB Dime is at least a couple of hundred dollar coin and the 58-P's in 66RD are $30-$40, I actually come out ahead on the deal, just not very far. In your world these are single digit coins in value but in the real world they do have worth.

Shamika

<< <i>I set up 3 of the 58-P's for 67RD... >>


Yep, it looked that way to me when I first read your initial post.

guysmy

<< <i>58-P's in 66RD are $30-$40, I actually come out ahead on the deal, just not very far. In your world these are single digit coins in value but in the real world they do have worth. >>



Would you be able to sell them for $30-$40 dollars in the "real world" or is that book value?

jacktheknife

Brian,

Just saw this on Teletrade. I have a fistful of the very same date with the very same rainbow toning that blow this thing away. My coins sit in 66 holders, go figure. I am sure your coins don't have all the chatter on the reverse, nor that nice big spot.

1958-D PCGS MS-67RD

Jack

clackamas

Jack,

That is a nice coin, but the "O" in "ONE" should have precluded 67 designation, even giving the benefit of the doubt that the spot grew after the coin was slabbed.

Cheers,

brian

lathmach

Geez, I've got a coupla original bank wrapped rolls of 1958 pennies.
I wonder how many $30-$40 coins there are in the bunch?
.........And I was gonna just toss them in one of the bags of wheats I sold. Guess I'm lucky I didn't.

Ray

dorkkarl

<< <i>Well Karl, since you would never have sent any of these coins in and the 57 66FB Dime is at least a couple of hundred dollar coin and the 58-P's in 66RD are $30-$40, I actually come out ahead on the deal >>

ok ok, i hear ya, but aside from the $$$, is there anything enjoyable about owning slabed coins like that???

K S

JRocco

I recently sent in a 44P that I thought was a lock 67Rd and it also came back 66Rd. They are being tight with 67's

morgannut2

Don't feel bad. I just sent in 1 DPL and 3 PL NGC Morgans and I got back ONE PL out of the whole mess. I'm sick.

JrGMan2004

<< <i>

<< <i>what were you expecting on the grades? >>



I set up 3 of the 58-P's for 67RD and the dime was so nice it should have been a 67FB. It is nicer than 3 of the MS67's I own. >>

You realize that the graders don't always see the coins in Invoice order, right? Set-ups really don't do anything, if the order they see the coins in is randomized.......