Rare Album Toning?

relayer

1935-S SAN DIEGO MS-67 WITH ALBUM TONING "RARE"

I don't know about this one. Accelerated toning?

fivecents

Looks very AT to me.

MICHAELDIXON

To me it looks like it was stored in a leather pouch. I have several coins which came out of an old time collection from West Virginia that have the same toning. NGC holdered the silver dollar, but it was the only one I sent in. IMO NT.

magikbilly

I wonder why it is not in a slab...I wonder why some of his other coins have this coloring if it is "rare"...I wonder why he grades a Proof IHC as MS (I hate that! )...I wonder about some of those 65's...I wonder why he just sold an "1887-O MORGAN DOLLAR MS-65 PL" for under $900....either the coin was wrong, or the grade, or the price..none of which makes me feel OK. All my humble opinion worth exactly 2 cents


Billy

dorkkarl

totally like pass on this coin

K S

nwcs

magikbilly

Here is a recent sale of his:

1903 BARBER QUARTER PROOF DEEP CAMEO MS-64++VERY RARE - sold with reserve met $460.01

Billy