Peace

Crazy4Coins

Grade opinions welcomed............

Peaceman

I bet the NTC slab is MS-65........

Put it in a PCGS/NGC slab and it's a 3.....

Peaceman

and that's streching it.... maybe a 2 in a PCGS.........

Crazy4Coins

Hey Steve,

62... that hurts

What do you see that would knock it down to a 62?



Randy

Baley

I think 62 is too low, this is an attractive coin with apparently nice surfaces, marks commensurate with MS63 but I agree, 64 would depend on how the cheek mark looks up close, as well as a couple other spots and toning. 64 not out of the question, imo, but 65 would be a pretty big stretch unless the luster looks better than the pics portray. The 24S is a fairly tough date/mm in gem, this looks like a strong 63 to weak 64, but would like to see the coin in a little bit better light.

for comparison, here's my coin which is probably about one grade point lower than yours, I like this one as a 62 or so





booming luster and great arm's-length eye appeal can only go so far against those cuts on her face..

Myqqy

I would say that it's too hard to estimate a grade with those pics- the lower halves are too dark to assess the amount of bagmarks and blemishes...