Eenie, Meenie, Mienie, Mantle.
elway65
Posts: 157
If you could own one of the following Mantle cards, which would you choose? (If you already own one or more of the listed, just pick the one you don't have yet.)
everywhere you go
there you are
marc in Hawaii
there you are
marc in Hawaii
0
Comments
Steve
2005 Origins Old Judge Brown #/20 and Black 1/1s, 2000 Ultimate Victory Gold #/25
2004 UD Legends Bake McBride autos & parallels, and 1974 Topps #601 PSA 9
Rare Grady Sizemore parallels, printing plates, autographs
Nothing on ebay
Always looking for Topps Salesman Samples, pre '51 unopened packs, E90-2, E91a, N690 Kalamazoo Bats, and T204 Square Frame Ramly's
aconte
there you are
marc in Hawaii
I voted before I read anyone's picks and rationale...jay
Website: http://www.qualitycards.com
There is a DanDee in Goodwin's auction, and on Mile High's site I think.
Elway - if you are selling these I am interested in the Stahl Meyer.
Collectable
there you are
marc in Hawaii
selection of Mickey Mantle cards that would comprise a dream master collection of those that combine varying amounts of beauty and scarcity.
But for sheer eye appeal that positively ARRESTS a card connoisseur's attention and makes him stare for an indefinite period of time, the
Stahl-Meyer Mantle is IT. Further, when you become educated about the history of these cards(and I would love to know more), and you
ponder the fact that they were issued FACE-AGAINST the wet, greasy franks as a package-stiffener, you come away with a multitude of
thoughts and emotions:
1. No wonder so few of these beautiful cards exist today
2. No wonder only a few of the fewer survived in PSA5, or better.
3. What were the Stahl-Meyer people thinking to go to the trouble of hiring the Milprint Company to create such gorgeous cards, and then
subject them to creases and stains and stamped numbers (a date, I suspect) before a mother could give her beloved child his treasure?
I realize card-collecting wasn't that serious then, and it was just a somewhat cheap promotional tool to sell more Stahl-Meyer hickory-
smoked frankfurts. But still, but still, .....
4. I wish that they had had a season-end opportunity for kids, or adults, to send in 2 labels and 50 cents for a set, But they didn't.
5. As long as we're dreaming, I wish it was 1953, and my mom and I were walking into the Stahl-Meyer office to beg, plead, scream,
and implore them to sell us a set. It might have worked. Judging by the number of nice specimens, nobody, or at least very, very
few, were successful.
6. If I were a fox, and I were honest about it, these cards are one batch of "grapes" that were just as nice and sweet as they could be!
Joe
Always looking for 1957 Topps BB in PSA 9!
of 1995. I've always enjoyed their write-ups of the lots. They throw in some significance of the time, and occasionally how earlier collectors
regarded the particular card and/or issue. Let's face it--it's the kinda of stuff we vintage collectors relish. Lately, they've included a little bit of
"be the first one on your block to own . . ." and have consciously appealed to collectors' possible vanity, which I don't care for, but that's their
choice and it obviously works. I've been trying to acquire some good research for an article(s) on the Stahl-Meyers, but it has been tough-
going. Some people have given superb interviews. Others who know A LOT wish to abstain. That is depressing. I almost got the
impression that one guy was so closed-mouth about it that he won't even talk to himself! But then, if he's still hunting for these
babies, an article might somehow scotch his efforts big-time. If he's a dealer of such cards, that might hurt his business because owners
of such rarities will wake up to the fact that they're sitting on gems. Wow, am I off-subject. Take care. -IndianaJones
renown "PSA Set Registry." Under "Baseball," click on "Player." Scroll down to "Mickey Mantle Master Set," and click on that. Now,
Scroll down to the 9th "Current Finest Collection;" there you will see "707 Sportscards- ltd- #7" and click on that. Finally, scroll down
to "1953 Stahl Meyer Mickey Mantle." You will find a camera icon beside this listing, and click on that. Levi Bleam is the ONLY ONE
I believe on the PSA Set Registry that owns this beauty. In fact, he owns ALL 3 YEARS; however, the 1953 is the only scan that he shows
of his Stahl-Meyers. As was mentioned, the same photo is used in each year. That is another discussion, and I've said enough. Take care.
--IndianaJones
nothing on me. Frank, I'm sorry that I confused you with AJW. However, I have good news for you. Levi Bleam's 1953 Stahl-Meyer
Mantle is FOR SALE. It's only $3,500. It is a PSA2, and while many wince at that price, it's because they don't realize what it is and
what's out there--very, very little. Most I would venture are held in collections with the tenacity of the giant squid in Disney's
"20,000 Leagues Under the Sea." But then for most of us, me included, $3,500 is not play money. I wish you the very best in your
quest, collector friend. Also, I trust it won't have to take a "body" to get one! Take care. --IndianaJones
'
I love the Stahl Meyers, especially the 1953s. I would be interested in the information you gathered on this set, but have no interest in more collectors being introduced to it! You wouldn't by any chance have an extra Campy cluttering up a showbox somewhere?
Collectable
<< <i>Indiana -
I love the Stahl Meyers, especially the 1953s. I would be interested in the information you gathered on this set, but have no interest in more collectors being introduced to it! You wouldn't by any chance have an extra Campy cluttering up a showbox somewhere? >>
Hello friend. I can well understand your preference for the 1953's. I honestly don't mind the neon-yellow borders, but if I had my "druthers",
I would much prefer the 1953's china-white borders also. Perhaps they switched to the neon-yellow to somehow mask the bow-wow
stains. Stains do not seem to show as badly on those cards. Unfortunately, that color is a bit loud, so to speak.
While I am very willing to share info, I would prefer to wait. Believe me, not to keep you dangling, but because I need some more substanciating
evidence of some information that I have gotten. Really, nothing that I have is that earth-shattering; however, I do feel that it is one of the
most fascinating, mysterious, and eye-appealing baseball card sets ever issued.
Lastly, yes, I do have a 1953 Roy Campanella. I hate to let you down though because it is not for sale. It is ungraded and probably a PSA4,
though they might give it a 3. If I were fortunate enough to upgrade it (FAT CHANCE), I would be glad to sell it to you. That great photo of
Roy, as you probably know, was used on sevcral cards. None of them IMHO can hold a candle to the Stahl-Meyer. Take care. -IndianaJones
The second best example of that picture I have seen is a Wheaties premium. Almost bought the Berk Ross a little while ago just to have it, but instead decided to wait. There was a nice pre-accident signed example of the photo in and auction (Hunts I think) a while back that went for a large chunk of change.
As for the numbers on the cards, I always thought they were lot numbers and not dates. It would be interesting to compile a list of all numbers which could shed some light on the subject. #203 seems to pop into my head.
Collectable
As for the numbers on the cards, I always thought they were lot numbers and not dates. It would be interesting to compile a list of all numbers which could shed some light on the subject. #203 seems to pop into my head. >>
The numbers on the cards is one of the mysteries that I would like to conclusively solve. I have heard several theories. The
possibility that they are indeed lot numbers is one of them. If you'd like to help me with this project, I could use your
assistance. Out of curiosity, have you ever seen the same lot #/date/whatever?!? on different cards from the same year?
Regardless, it's been fun corresponding. Take care. --IndianaJones
Shoot me an email : danstudebaker(.at.)hotmail.com
Collectable