Guess the grade on this Morgan Dollar (large images).

Russ

I am inspired by Coinguy1's thread.





Note: I can't remember if I've done this one before so if I have and you know the grade, please play dumb.

Note 2: It's not my coin, I was just lucky enough to get to image it.

Russ, NCNE

paigowjohnny

PF 67

ER

PF66 CAM.
Where did you hide the hairlines?

kieferscoins

PR-67.

Cameron Kiefer

wam98

Proof- 68

ss350camaro

Nice Picture Russ but i see what looks like hints of Photoshop type 'repairs'.

Russ

<< <i>Nice Picture Russ but i see what looks like hints of Photoshop type 'repairs'. >>



You see nothing of the sort.

Russ, NCNE

ss350camaro

<< <i>You see nothing of the sort. >>



ya, right


(oh wait, i forgot the )

seanq

My first instinct was to bodybag it for altered images. My second was to call it PF64CAM. I think I see hints of hairlines in front of the portrait on the obverse.

As always, I reserve the right to be utterly full of it.


Sean Reynolds

sliderider

Remember Marks thread was about deceiving images and Russ has already shown us pics of a badly scarred Kennedy that looked DCAM in his original photos, so I say this is a lower grade than it appears, as well. PF 61.

XpipedreamR

You have posted that one before. But I'll play dumb; it won't be hard.










ATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATATAT!!!!!!!

dorkkarl

pr-60

i guess if it's slabed, it would say "cam" as well

K S

mhammerman

Are you sure someone didn't run up to Philly and have them make that one fresh? Pretty darn nice morgan, would look even greater if it were in my hot little gloved hand!!!

ss350camaro

ttt

(a coin thread that's sinking too fast)

SethChandler

Yucky washed out unoriginal Proof.

Coinhusker1

PF 64 CAM

coinfreak499

66

coinbuf

The hairlines bring it down say PF60

Chris

dorkkarl

WELL???

what did i win???

(russ i left myself open here....)

K S

seanq

<< <i>WELL???

what did i win???

>>




Well Russ did say he was inspired by coinguy1's thread, if so we have a few more days to wait.


Sean Reynolds

Betta285

PF66 CAM

Myqqy

You've done this one before, but it doesn't matter because I can't remember the grade.....

How about PR66cam?

relayer

PR66CAM

or

MS67DMPL

coinguy1

Dipped (and now retoning) cameo Proof.

Numismanic

PF 63 CAM

Baley

I'll guess PR62CAM; photograph it from a different angle and some minor to moderate hairlines will show..

DesertRat

Iono!

coinkat

PR63 cam that was dipped. could grade worse depending on hairlines...

poorguy

Too many hairlines in the fields. Nice cameo. I'd say PR62.

I would also have to agree that the coin looks as it's been dipped in the past.

airplanenut

PR63CAM

tippingmyhat

pr67dcam

clw54

MS66 DMPL

clw54

Geez, I shoulda read the other answers and seen that it was a proof.

LincolnCentMan

PR67CAM

David

dragon

I don't know about grading US coinage, but that looks like a nice shiny coin to me, and a pretty design too.

Baley

aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand? the suspense is killin' me.

Aethelred

Based on the sharp detail it does look proof. The trick is knowing if what I see is just toning or hairlines. I'm going to say PR-65CAM.

rainbowroosie

Russ,
Excellent photo, but you can't see hairlines on a photo....that said, based on the photo looks 67 Cam.....

dorkkarl

so who won???

K S

Shamika

PF65CAM

smselvek

MS66PL, just a guess.

Numismanic

And the grade is?

Wolf359

PR63CAM. I had Russ photo it for me a while back and ask his opinion on the grade.

Newmismatist

Pr63 to Pr66 depending on what pops out at 'cha when you rotate it in the light - Proofs can be images so that may flaws "disappear" due to the angle of the light. JMHO

Edited to add: See what happens when you post BEFORE you read the whole thread - I coulda saved the "guess" and just clicked to the last post