Anyone care to play "Guess the NGC Submission Grades?" All 8 are Toned Morgans

TonedCoinTrader

I thought it might be a little more fun for you to Guess the grades I got on my latest submission, rather than just list them.
This is an NGC submission with a total of 8 Morgans. Feel free to comment on any of the coins you wish.

Oh and the grades have not been posted on my site so there can be no cheating
But a couple members may know the grade on 1 or 2 coins but not the others.

Scott


1886-P



1889-P



1900-P



1886-P



1885-O



1883-O



1886-P



1884-O

sTONER

i got it SCOTT, they are all MS beauties, with a few stars,,STEVE

TonedCoinTrader

Maybe so Maybe No

100proof1957

Not to be rude.
Au
Au
MS64
XF45
MS63
MS64
AU
AU

TonedCoinTrader

That's not rude.

Your opinion is your opinion

coinbuf

OK here goes

64
63
64
63
65
65
65
63

How did I do?

Chris

wam98

1886.......AU-58
1889.......AU-55
1900.......AU-58
1886.......AU-50
1885-O...MS-64
1883-O...MS-64 weak
1886.......MS-63 weak
1884-O...MS-63 weak

This should be interesting.

Nice original Morgan dollars IMO

sTONER

ok SCOTT enough time , the suspense is killing me

TonedCoinTrader

That's everyone who want's to play?

100proof1957

TTT

Crazy4Coins

1886.......AU-58
1889.......MS-63
1900.......MS-61
1886.......MS-63
1885-O...MS-64
1883-O...MS-64
1886.......MS-64
1884-O...MS-62

TonedCoinTrader

Ok Ok here are the grades recieved:

<FONT face=Verdana>1. 1886-P NGC MS 64
2. 1889-P NGC MS 64 Shold be a 65 but I guess the price jump from 64 to 65 held it back.
3. 1900-P NGC MS 64
4 1886-P NGC MS 64 Would be a 65 but has a old time scratch on cheek under the toning.
5. 1885-O NGC MS 63 Has the Look of a 65 but shallow contact marks on the cheek under the toning took it to a 3
6. 1886-P NGC MS 64*
7. 1883-O NGC MS 64*
8. 1884-O NGC MS 62

Here are Raw pic's of the 64*'s Color


</FONT>

tgilliams

1884-P MS64
1887-P MS63
1900-P MS64
1886-P MS65
1885-O MS63
1883-O MS66
1886-P MS65
1884-O MS64

coinbuf

Well I was pretty close to your actual grades; now I just need to figure out why I'm never that close when I submit coins. LOL

Chris

ultradmpldollars

Pretty rough there Proof....

airplanenut

That textile 84-O is sweet. Must be why I bought it

100proof1957

The weak strikes really got me !
i dont play with morgs much,at least if i was a buyer i wouldnt get harpooned !

BigD5

63
64
63
62 (au?)
64
63
63 (*?)
63

BigD5

Duh! Grades were posted.