1891-CC, how would it grade? (larger pics added)

DesertRat

I'm still learning and haven't looked at circulated Morgans for grading yet.



Sorry had the smaller pics first but fixed it.

Wondo

small picks, but I'm going EF40

Cam40

35...about. pic too small for accurate grading

edited to add: Better pics. Thanks. I still say 35..about..

sliderider

I agree with Cam. 40 is a tad liberal, IMO.

clw54

VG10, maybe F12.

Cam40

Maybe clw is right. May be only a Fine. VF20 on a really sunny day.

K6AZ

Looks to me like a F15/VF20. I'd be able to give a better guess if the images were a bit larger.

BAJJERFAN

vf20 tops at PCGS
more likely f12/f15

Wondo

Sorry, no breasts. But I'm still higher than y'all with the larger pics. VF-25ish. Tell me where I have gone wrong, please.

Poppy

coin grades vf25.

clw54

<< <i>Maybe clw is right. May be only a Fine. VF20 on a really sunny day. >>


I was basing it on actual PCGS Morgans. I have an F12, F15, and VF20. It's not as good as my VF20. The obverse looks more worn than my F12, but the reverse might be a little better.

It could be the photos aren't picking up all the detail, or the grader who graded my "control sample" wasn't feeling generous that day. Thinking about it some more, however, I do think my VG10 guess was low. It's better than that. I hope it gets submitted so we'll found out someday.


Edited to add hastily snapped photos of my VF20 1892-CC

Cam40

its so difficult to judge coin grades by pics but, i get a feel of Desert Rat`s `91 CC is every bit a 20
compared to your 20 clw.
reason why i say that is the slabbed coin looks cleaned and alittle un-natural where,DR`s ...well probably
cleaned as well, but doesnt have a new dipped look.
sorry no offense personally.
just interpreting the pics as i see them.

SethChandler

VF25

BigAl

comes back pcgs VF20

RickMilauskas

F 15 from my view....maybe an outside shot at VF 20.