PCGS Submission Results
numonebuyer
Posts: 2,136 ✭
I have never undergraded PCGS so much in my life. I agreed with PCGS on only 3 of 20. I was high on 5 of 20. I was low on 12 of 20.
In hindsight, I was obviously overly conservative on the last 13 (as I assumed they were all circulated). The last 13 I was submitting for a friend, so I had never studied them for more than a few seconds per coin (I have to blame my poor grading on something). My coins were the first seven, in which I agreed with PCGS on 2 of 7, high on 4 of 7 and low on 1 of 7.
1. My grade MS-62, PCGS grade MS-63
2. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade AU-58
3. My grade MS-61, PCGS grade AU-58
4. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade MS-63
5. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade MS-63
6. My grade MS-60, PCGS grade AU-58
7. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade XF-40
8. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55 Pretty good for grading a Peace Dollar
9. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-50
10. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55
11. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55
12. My grade F-12, PCGS grade BODDY BAG
13. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade AU-55
14. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
15. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
16. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-62
17. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade AU-50
18. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
19. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-64
20. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-65
In hindsight, I was obviously overly conservative on the last 13 (as I assumed they were all circulated). The last 13 I was submitting for a friend, so I had never studied them for more than a few seconds per coin (I have to blame my poor grading on something). My coins were the first seven, in which I agreed with PCGS on 2 of 7, high on 4 of 7 and low on 1 of 7.
1. My grade MS-62, PCGS grade MS-63
2. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade AU-58
3. My grade MS-61, PCGS grade AU-58
4. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade MS-63
5. My grade MS-63, PCGS grade MS-63
6. My grade MS-60, PCGS grade AU-58
7. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade XF-40
8. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55
Pretty good for grading a Peace Dollar9. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-50
10. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55
11. My grade AU-50, PCGS grade AU-55
12. My grade F-12, PCGS grade BODDY BAG
13. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade AU-55
14. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
15. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
16. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-62
17. My grade XF-45, PCGS grade AU-50
18. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-63
19. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-64
20. My grade AU-58, PCGS grade MS-65
0
Comments
Nice results overall!
I'll betcha those 21-D's have nice die cracks, no??
Boy, if I can only say the same thing that would make me so happy. Maybe on the submission I have in right now.