Strike vs. Pizzazz dilema

Wondo

I have a dilemma. Got a stunning $20 Lib sent to me today - it glows, cartwheels, and is a fine (see I didn't say PQ ) example of an MS63 coin. First glance I would say 64 if I was asked to grade it ( But I ain't no expert). Anyway, Upon closer examination, the strike is a little soft on stars one and two and on the reverse eagle's neck.

Winter's book says these guys are generally well-struck. I don't know - that is my only reference. Does anyone know more about the striking characteristics of the 1893s $20 Lib?

The eye appeal is excellent, but the strike is not as strong as is possible. Any info, input, or advice would be appreciated.

Thanks.

coinguy1

Wondo, PM sent with pics.

Wondo

Mark,

I don't care what the other board members say about you.

You are a good guy in my book.

When are you gonna get some $20's in stock?

tjkillian

Luster is nice, but I'm a strike kind of guy. Give me a fully struck coin with less luster than a super lusterous, poorly struck coin any day.

Tom

DennisH

I, on the other hand, am a lustre guy. So, if it's basically a bullion date as opposed to a scarce "collecting" date, I'd go with eye appeal.

lordmarcovan

Oh.

For some reason, my eyes read this title as "Strike vs. Pizza".

I've never worked anywhere that went on strike, but it doesn't sound like fun.

I like pizza, though. No contest.



PS- as to the REAL topic of this thread, I would have to say I usually go for luster and pizzazz over strike, but it depends on a coin-by-coin analysis, as well as the type.

lordmarcovan

PS- (again)-if the luster cartwheels on that coin, like you said, a slightly flat star or two would not stop me from pouncing on it.

A $20 Lib with cartwheel luster is a beautiful sight.

LanLord

<< <i>Oh. For some reason, my eyes read this title as "Strike vs. Pizza". I've never worked anywhere that went on strike, but it doesn't sound like fun. I like pizza, though. No contest. PS- as to the REAL topic of this thread, I would have to say I usually go for luster and pizzazz over strike, but it depends on a coin-by-coin analysis, as well as the type. >>

I get the feeling Lord M was hungry when he was reading this thread

Wondo

<< <i>A $20 Lib with cartwheel luster is a beautiful sight. >>



'Tis true. 'Tis true.


I feel like one of those really bad Bud commercials.

lordmarcovan

Nope- just stuffed myself with Polk Flied Lice and Beef Lo Mein.

But it ain't hard to see what track my mind usually follows. No wonder I'm built like Michael Moore.

coinguy1

<< <i>When are you gonna get some $20's in stock? >>

Wondo, I've been trying to buy choice ones (MS 63 and better) at a few dollars back of spot and not having any luck. I'm getting ready to bite the bullet, up my buy price to spot and hope to have dozens of "gems" available any minute now.

Wondo

<< <i>Wondo, I've been trying to buy choice ones (MS 63 and better) at a few dollars back of spot and not having any luck. I'm getting ready to bite the bullet, up my buy price to spot and hope to have dozens of "gems" available any minute now. >>




Mark,

Wait a minute. Are you a coin.........dealer?