Who all thinks that whoever grades your coins..

Boom

Along with everyone that handles them, should be made to sign your invoice? I am editing what I have said until I speak with Mr. Hall.

Russ

<< <i>I'd like to know who cleaned mine.

Odd, I didn't ask for anyone to clean them! >>



You should post a question in Q&A and ask David Hall who cleaned your coins.

Russ, NCNE

Boom

Again, edited by me until I take this up with Mr. Hall

Boom

I'm putting an end to this right now until I speak with David personally. Suffice to say I should have done so to begin with. It is not my intent to make him or anyone affiliated with PCGS look bad publicly. What started out as a question should have simply stayed that way.

Myqqy

Do you have any before/after pics? What type of coin(s) are you talking about?

coppercoins

Hmm...since I grade all my own coins, someone else cleaning them would be a bit difficult.

Boom

I'm putting an end to this right now until I speak with David personally. Suffice to say I should have done so to begin with. It is not my intent to make him or anyone affiliated with PCGS look bad publicly. What started out as a question should have simply stayed that way.

MrEureka

Because this is a public forum with a fair number of newbies, this needs to be said:

In the past 15 years, PCGS and NGC have graded 20 million coins. I've been a full time dealer through that entire time period, and I've never heard of either service cleaning a coin without authorization.

Boom - Please stop wasting our time. Thank you.

XpipedreamR

What kind of cleaning are you talking about? Why do you think they would clean a coin...what's in it for them?

Bear

If Brasso is good enough to remove scratches off my slabs,

it should be good enough to clean scratches off my coins.

Boom

Once again I allowed my emotions get the better of me. I thought I could get over it but this has been festering since I opened the envelope. I am sure that what was done was done in good faith and that PCGS was only trying to help in some way.

This is the only possible explanation for what transpired. I certainly would not seek to embarass PCGS or Mr. Hall. either publicly or in private. I am at fault here for going about this the wrong way.

FrattLaw

TTT for the fact that Boom is trying the higher road approach to possibly a terrible situation.

Good-luck with it.

Michael

dorkkarl

<< <i>Who all thinks that whoever grades your coins.. Along with everyone that handles them, should be made to sign your invoice? >>

not me. ridiculous to believe that pcgs should do that, when they clearly & explicitly advertise that they use consensus grading. i'm sure that you know that danged well, too, so since you know what you are getting into, you have no grounds to complain.

K S