SAE Collectors: Does this look real?

MJPHELAN · June 20, 2004 9:18PM

Here is a 1995-W SAE on E-bay. The photo looks more like the copies on E-bay, or do you think it is just a bad photo?

1995-W SAE

Mark

JeffinMich · June 20, 2004 9:24PM

I dunno....but I see is not allowing any returns. Danger Will Robinson!!

razorface1027 · June 20, 2004 9:27PM

....but I see is not allowing any returns. Danger Will Robinson!!

Look out for this one! 3 feedback to boot.

There's another 95-W on the Bay. It has a reserve on it. This one looks too funky...JMO

Furthermore, when someone is trying to sell that which is unique, they usually post a pic. In this case, it would be a CLEAR pic of the reverse with a blown up "W"

MJPHELAN · June 20, 2004 9:37PM

I hope the high bidder (1500 currently) knows what he is doing.

razorface1027 · June 20, 2004 10:08PM

I sent him/her this...Let's see if they change it.

Hello;
Would you mind supplying more pics? The reverse & a blown-up pic of the mint mark while capturing the reverse at the same time. Those that are interested wouldn't be skeptical about your auction. Just some sound advice from a fellow eBayer...:-)

wjd283 · June 20, 2004 10:34PM

<< <i>There is absolutely NO reserve to meet >>

Except the $1500 starting price!

meos1 · June 20, 2004 11:11PM

Sure looks strange to me. Keep in mind these coins are well above that mark. Better off going and finding a real one.

Dan

nankraut · June 20, 2004 11:15PM

WOW! Red flag on this one. Somebody's going to be taken for an unpleasant ride, IMHO.

MJPHELAN · June 21, 2004 3:31AM

I have now requested a photo of the reverse. Hopefully I'll get one.

Mark

PCBUM · June 21, 2004 3:41AM

On description it's mentions that coin comes in velvet blue box. I don't think they were also shipped or sold from the Mint in these boxes? My dad has five sets of the gold’s with the Silver Eagle W Mint; I thought this was the only way to get these coins. This auction does look fishy.....

meos1 · June 21, 2004 4:06AM

PCBUM - I too have the 95 W and it does come in a red folder with four gold proof coins. The little blue box was the packaging for the 1995 P proof.

Dan

airplanenut · June 21, 2004 4:14AM

I see nothing wrong... the coin's in "emaculate" condition.

epicrecipe · June 21, 2004 4:55AM

Proceed with caution. I've seen several 1995-w Proof "commeratives" on ebay like this one and this one.

Some have moderately deceptive descriptions like this one. I noticed some of these auctions use the same descriptions and photos.

Anyone know who makes the knock offs?

Steve27 · June 21, 2004 4:57AM

I think he took the picture from Tulving's site and cropped it:

"His" pic:

MJPHELAN · June 21, 2004 5:00AM

I don't know who makes the copies. They are legal as copy is printed on the reverse. I just hate deceptive ads that try to make them look genuine.

epicrecipe · June 21, 2004 5:05AM

Oh, and yes the 1995-W SAEs were originally only available with the 1995-W gold proof set and it has a "w" mark on the reverse. The 1995-P would have been available with a blue US Mint cardboard boax containing a blue velvet box and COA.

I noticed this auction this weekend also. Too little seller history, only a single stock photo and the recent appearance of copies made me stray away. Perhaps the seller knows more than us and has reason to trust the transaction. More knowledge can position one to win a great deal. I sincerely hope so in this case! Otherwise, if it sounds too good...

razorface1027 · June 21, 2004 10:10AM

I just received the reply from this seller....

Ok, I will try to scan some photos and post them on the site.

Thanks for the info.
John

MJPHELAN · June 21, 2004 10:13AM

Here is my reply from the seller:

Mark, I will try to scan the coin in and get more photos. I will also
try to post them on the site.

Thanks,
John

MJPHELAN · June 21, 2004 11:45PM

Do you think it would be wrong to e-mail the high bidder and warn them this may be a copy (possibly unknown to seller)?

Mark

red68 · June 22, 2004 12:24AM

Looks like a rip off. I would never buy one that high from some one who only has 3 feedbacks better steer clear of this one. And no return.

MJPHELAN · June 22, 2004 12:34AM

The only reason I am following these on E-bay is that I plan to sell my soon (PCGS certified). I am trying to get an idea what they are selling for. I just hate seeing people get ripped off.

razorface1027 · June 22, 2004 12:35AM

I just received the reply from this seller....

Sorry, but as a seller, and I'm speaking solely about myself; I, by this time, would've ammended this auction to render the pics necessary to appease the querys that potential customers have posed. So, at this juncture, I'm led to believe that this auction is BOGUS. Refer to my prior posts. Someone else inquired about posting pics too.

cdwegner · June 22, 2004 1:36AM

I asked him yesterday for a picture of the reverse, also.

I never heard back.

Seems kind of iffy at this point.

c

Russ · June 22, 2004 1:41AM

<< <i>I think he took the picture from Tulving's site and cropped it: >>

Steve is right. The auction pic was definitely ripped from Tulving. They are identical.

Russ, NCNE

MJPHELAN · June 22, 2004 10:33AM

Should I contact the seller with these points and perhaps prevent a rip off?

Mark

DorkGirl · June 22, 2004 10:40AM

He has cancelled that auction and relisted it with different pics, way different pics---new auction

cdwegner · June 23, 2004 12:03PM

still think it's not real?

cdwegner · June 24, 2004 2:18PM

it's getting bids now.

harbon · June 24, 2004 4:19PM

Ooof, ebay needs a "comments" page for every auction.

alergar · June 24, 2004 4:27PM

Scam, Scam, Scam, Scam - Notice the auction has been withdrawn by seller !!!!! Hmmmm.

cdwegner · June 25, 2004 12:41AM

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=39488&item=3918260907

The new one is not withdrawn. It's getting bids.

MJPHELAN · July 1, 2004 11:48PM

It sold, and positive feedback was left!

SAE Collectors: Does this look real?

Comments

Leave a Comment