SLQ ebay auction - AT or NT

JxnBoy

1917 T2

Not sure. Looks OK around "LIBERTY", but I'm not sure. Cleaned and retoned? Just plain toned? Or just plain AT? Whaddya think?

rlawsha

Just an uneducated guess, I would say natural toning but cleaned.

ddbird

Def NT, but not sure about cleaned!

coinguy1

If the images are accurate I firmly believe that the coin has been cleaned and has (or was) retoned.

ms70

<< <i>Just an uneducated guess, I would say natural toning but cleaned. >>



I have that feeling too.

Russ

Looks like an improperly neutralized dip.

Russ, NCNE

JxnBoy

I was leaning that way too. I'm also not too crazy about the seller's "This coin is worth $1,000,000 in MS!!!" hyperbole.

291fifth

My guess that is that is was cleaned some time ago and now is retoning naturally.

RGT

My first thought looking at the pictures was cleaned and retoned (probably naturally). Then I looked at the seller and my second thought was "stay away".

grip

Looks Cleaned and AT'd.

Placid

Why would anyone buy from that ?

rlawsha

<< <i>Why would anyone buy from that ? >>



Oh my gosh, I didn't notice who the seller was, RUN AWAY FAST!

Myqqy

I still think nascar and numismatics don't mix.....

jeffnpcb

I guess we could all have a severe case of tunnel vision! I enjoy NASCAR on the major tracks, 2 miles or better! I enjoy NHRA drag racing even more from the mechanical and engineering aspects! Over 6,000 horse on nitro-methane and run a 1/4 mile in the mid 4 second range. What kind of thrill might that be and watching, versus sitting on your duff with a loop looking at coins or any other hobby! It all goes full circle, that regardless of the hobby, it still takes money to enjoy!

airplanenut

I doubt the coin is any good, especially considering the seller. Don't buy it.

KlectorKid

Cleaned retoned

BigD5

I go with the "was" retoned. I don't think it's real. Cooked is the first thing that came to my mind.