recent sub

ldferg

1 11904062 1970 TOPPS 411 DODGERS TEAM N/A 7
2 11904063 1980 TOPPS 482 RICKEY HENDERSON N/A 8
3 11904064 1980 TOPPS 482 RICKEY HENDERSON N/A 8
4 11904065 1980 TOPPS 482 RICKEY HENDERSON N/A 9OC
5 11904066 1979 TOPPS 700 REGGIE JACKSON N/A 8
6 11904067 1979 TOPPS 115 NOLAN RYAN N/A 8
7 11904068 1979 TOPPS 39 DALE MURPHY N/A 8
8 11904069 1975 TOPPS 202 1964-MVP'S K.BOYER/B.ROBINSON Not Holdered, Evidence of Trimming
9 11904070 1987 FLEER 604 BARRY BONDS N/A 8OC
10 11904071 1980 TOPPS 482 RICKEY HENDERSON N/A 8
11 11904072 1980 TOPPS 580 NOLAN RYAN N/A 9

what do you do when something comes back as "trimmed" and you believe this is not correct?

A761506

measure the card, nothing to it

ldferg

will do. btw, all of the 79 and 80 cards in this submission were pulled from vending or wax. the 9oc henderson is awesome except for the centering.

gemint

Well, normally I would resubmit it. But we're talking about a '75 common, so it's probably not worth the effort/expense.

envoy98

I wish they would change that qualifier from "Evidence of Trimming" to Min-Size-Requirement. I know they have that one. Ev of Trimming should be reserved for those cards that have vertical lines on the edges from a paper cutter, or a hook on one end or the other. I think though, that since the Evd of Trimm doesn't refund your money but min size req does....well... you do the math.

I had 2 62T cards come back "Evidence of Restoration/Recoloring" both of these cards had been in a cigar box for 30 years in my step-dads collection. The other two I sent in on the same submission came out of the same box. They were only PSA 5/6 material anyway... I just gave them back to him. 2 holdered, 2 not.

SDavid

I also had a few cards rejected for trimming recently. One was from a factory sealed set and the other was straight from wax. Whatever.

I also wish they'd be more careful how they label these cards. In this case, I know the cards weren't trimmed b/c I pulled them myself, but what if I had bought them raw from somebody? By using the evid of trimming label instead of the min. size deal, PSA would have basically been telling me that the dealer ripped me off when in fact he hadn't. I wonder how many squabbles between buyers and sellers have been caused by this?

EagleEyeKid

For "evidence of trimming"; I wish they would mark or state exactly where it was trimmed.....would be helpful.

SDavid

Eagleeyekid -

Speaking of trimming...what did those dealers have to say when you told them about the submission from hell?

aro13

EagleEyeKid - Interesting that you mention that - a few times I have had cards returned with a little note stating where the card was trimmed but that has not happened in a while.