My Callahans............:(

Aknot

envoy98

Wow, those look really undergraded. I have read some of your posts about these "Hoping to have first psa 10 callahans"

Do these have some flaw that you can see now that you have them back? They look gorgeous in the scans.

Aknot

I would be lying if I said no. I dont lie. "Some" appear to be not as white as I thought. The Dimag I KNEW was not that good and was actually counting on a 6. The Honus is SHARP AS A TACK except for the "slight?" centering up front. The back of the Honus is PERFECT.



My Bender has SLIGHT discolration around the "edges" and an upper right corner dink. Now why in hell would I submit a card with a defect like that? (you cant see it) Not happy with the answer I received from CS. Maybe I mispacked it when shipping. Sorry I followed your "rules".

Gabby....He is as sharp as the Honus with very little if any discoloration. The back is a little off center. Maybe a lot you tell me:


As for the others. Well Im tired. It will do no good to "gripe". Im going to dinner with my wife and will put all this behind me. I will be submitting some other stuff in about 2 weeks. If my "eye" sucks like it apparently sucked here I will stop using them. Maybe it is me.

Cubfan

How do the corners look under a loupe?

WinPitcher

Jim I think u did well.................nm7 and nm-mnt 8 are hi grades for old cards............a well centered hi end 7 is a nice sweet card. I am always on the lookout for such cards and in time they have the most upside potential. in any event put a smile on ya face damnit!

dbj77

Toning is not supposed to count off on cards, otherwise we wouldn't see all the PSA 8 Play Ball cards that look like my cat peed on them.

itsawonderfullife

Here's my Callahan, but it's a bit dirty....

envoy98

Clever.