I Just Got Roosevelt Dime Grades!!

Rampage

Not bad for my first Roosevelt Dime submission. Being that all of these are beautiful mint set toners, I thought I would score at least one STAR, but I did not. To me, these all have great eye appeal, but I guess beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I will post pictures when they come back.

Richard.

Line--Date/MM--Den--Grade--My Comments.
001--1958-------10C--MS66--Great mint set toner with nice colors.

002--1958-------10C--MS66--Great mint set toner with nice colors.

003--1958-------10C--MS67--Very pleased. Great mint set toner with nice colors.

004--1957 D---10C--MS65--Wonder what happened here. Still a nice mint set toner.

005--1956 D---10C--MS66--Great mint set toner with nice colors.

006--1956-------10C--MS66--Great mint set toner with nice colors.

007--1959-------10C--MS67--Very pleased. Great mint set toner with nice colors and very deserving of the grade.

Dabigkahuna

Richard,

Nice!


Any chance of seeing some of the color? I picked up a roll of 46-S with some "EOR" Toners but I can't get the pics to show?





Larry
Dabigkahuna

Stooge

Rampage...Those are some very good grades. You are lacking the FB's of course, but overall some very decent grades. It is very difficult to obtain a 67 of some of those Roosies!



Later, Paul.

Rampage

Larry,

When I get the coins back I will be taking some scans to post on the forum.

Paul,

I knew a few would not make the FT, but the colors were so nice and the coins were practically mark free that I just had to send them in. I did, however, think that a couple would get the FT designation. No biggie. Still very nice coins.

Colorfulcoins

Richard, congrats! Seeing that you expected some to get stars, these were NGC holdered? More than a few would say NGC is just as tough as PCGS these days....what do you think of your grades - think you would have gotten the same grades at PCGS?

rainbowroosie

http://forums.collectors.com/messageview.cfm?catid=26&threadid=284779link

Dennis88

Congrats!!!

Dennis

Rampage

<< <i>Richard, congrats! Seeing that you expected some to get stars, these were NGC holdered? More than a few would say NGC is just as tough as PCGS these days....what do you think of your grades - think you would have gotten the same grades at PCGS? >>



Craig,

Yes, these are NGC holdrred coins. I am quite happy with my grades. These were mainly submitted because of the awesome toning on the coins. I expected MS65/66 coins, never expected MS67 coins. I also thought for sure about three or four would have gone FT, but maybe I don't know what NGC looks for on these coins. But, like I said this was my first Rossevelt Dime submission to either of the services.

I feel the coins would generally grade the same (maybe even a couple of FB) at PCGS.

Colorfulcoins

Richard, if you think your 59P MS67 has FB (vis-a-via the PCGS Standard), send it in for a cross - a pretty toned 59P in PCGS MS67FB is a very nice coin and worth in the $500-1000 range!

Course, a 58P in MS67 with Full Bands would be one heckof a PCGS cross (currently PCGS and NGC pop0) !!!!!!

Would love to see some pictures! Love them toners.........

braddick

rainbowroosie

Craig,
Super pretty 47D -- second prettiest I've ever seen!!!!!!!!!!

onlyroosies

Bill, How do you know thats a 47D craig is showing.

Nick

Nevermind I see where craig list it below

rainbowroosie

Cause I read his URL?????

Rampage

Craig,

Those are some lovely coins. I will try to scan the coins when they come back. If the scans don't come out well, then I will send them to one of our board members (who I need to send other coins to) to get imaged.

Richard.

Dabigkahuna

Nice colors!