Home PSA Set Registry Forum

Who won last nights fight?

Since there was no knockout, you be the judge.

Comments

  • How about adding a vote for "who didn't care"?
  • You cared enough to post that you didn't care. I dont care whether you care as long as you judge the fight. It was a classic that will go down as one of the all time greats. Draws suck! Please help bring the fight to a conclusion.
  • murcerfanmurcerfan Posts: 2,329 ✭✭
    Can we vote for who lost worse ?

    edited to say:

    'cause the only winner I saw in the entire thread was Julie Vogner....... who I don't know, but she gets my vote anyways........ mostly because shes's a she...................that and she owns an old hockey card of Tiny Thompson image
  • I cannot change the poll. This thing is damn close. We may need to call Don King to schedule the rematch.

  • I don't care and didn't bother to read through all the crap that went back and forth. Sorry for the bother.


  • << <i>Can we vote for who lost worse ?

    edited to say:

    'cause the only winner I saw in the entire thread was Julie Vogner....... who I don't know, but she gets my vote anyways........ mostly because shes's a she...................that and she owns an old hockey card of Tiny Thompson image >>



    she also has a few Old Judge Charles Radbourn(e) cards. i've always wanted one from his playing days
  • AlanAllenAlanAllen Posts: 1,530 ✭✭✭
    Winner: Dick Towle
    Loser: Everyone else in the hobby
    No such details will spoil my plans...
  • GriffinsGriffins Posts: 6,076 ✭✭✭
    Julie always wins. She's the class of the board, and gets more undeserved abuse than the rest put together.
    I think when something like this goes on we all lose.

    Always looking for Topps Salesman Samples, pre '51 unopened packs, E90-2, E91a, N690 Kalamazoo Bats, and T204 Square Frame Ramly's

  • The punch summary is:

    Mike Wentz uses a guy that restores cards so that he can "learn" how to spot restorations.
    Greg thinks Mikes not being honest about this.

    Greg thinks Mike punched a guy at the National and posted a police record to prove it
    Mike thinks the police record is actually for Gregs arrest for being a pimp.

    Mike thinks Greg is either incompetent in grading or dishonest.
    Greg claims his slip is merely an honest mistake.

    Greg thinks Mike trimmed the PSA 9 King Kelly card and wondered why Mike didnt get SGC to grade it.
    Mike responded that he thinks Greg is a pimp. A dishonest or incompetent pimp at that.

    Mike wonders why Greg is submitting cards to PSA through a third party for grading while he is making negative posts about PSA.
    Greg claims the card that he submitted to PSA through the third party for was actually for an unnamed fourth party so he doesnt really use PSA. He merely took the card from the third party and handed it to the fourth party who sent the card to PSA. Then the card went back from PSA to the fourth party, then to Greg, then to the third party who was thusly and profusely villified for using a grading company that is clearly not up to Gregs standards.

    Mike wonders why all the fighting with so many parties involved?

    I may have missed some punches as these two heavyweights were well oiled and skilled at deflecting punches.



  • sounds like my prom night
  • We can have a new poll to judge your prom night if she is willing to come on the boards and debate what actually happened.
  • schr1stschr1st Posts: 1,677 ✭✭
    I'd have to say Greg won, since he was the one that forced Mike into making comments about Greg being a pimp and all the rest. When you have to start doing that, you've lost. Greg in 14 rounds via a TKO.
    Who is Rober Maris?
  • Since it is this close, do you think we can get Joe Orlando to reinstate Mike and Greg's ids for one night on these boards so they can finish this once and for all? I still feel cheated.
  • kobykoby Posts: 1,699 ✭✭
    I don't know whether either of them actually won, but nothing can be more damaging than this:




    << <i>MW
    (no login)
    Reply April 22 2004, 7:50 PM

    Greg,

    I freely admit that I have purchased cards from Dick Towle ("Gone with the Stain") and sent cards to him for restoration.
    >>





    I think that something like this is good for the hobby. To know that crap like this can go on will make us all a little more weary when we purchase high dollar cards, not only from BMW, but from anyone.

  • Winner: Dick Towle
    Loser: Everyone else in the hobby

    I second that emotion.
  • This poll is like having to chose your favorite dictator: Stalin(the real one from Russia that killed more people than any other dictator - not the moron on this board) or Hitler.

    Both of these guys are as dirty as they come. Both of them, notably MW would rather get the last word than do the right thing. MW's style in undeniable:

    1. Deny everything (very Clintonesque)
    2. Change the subject
    3. Throw in a personal attack (to MW that's funny)
    4. Completly ignore the original argument and continue the path of personal attack

    MW has through his ramblings alienated more people in this hobby than WIWAG could ever have done. Great Job Mikey, I see you have never lost your touch. As far as the arrest report goes, please that was 2002 top story and everyone knows that it did happen, no matter how much you try to lie.

    Now in addition to beating up your customers (OK, ex-customers for the most), humiliating them, lying to them now you are in possession of restored/altered cards. Gawd no wonder PSA wants nothing to do you. I wonder if SGC is now finding out the same things that PSA found out about you a few years ago. So what's left for MW when SGC drops him? Hello Beckett....

    Another nail in MW's coffin. Can't wait for the last one to be hammered in.
Sign In or Register to comment.