I would like to bid but I can not believe the grade

newport

http://apps.heritagecoin.com/common/view_item.php?Sale_No=346&Lot_No=6310&sid=FA6FEEBC5BE3DCA01890CFDB8DF68E7C

Please help with the Heritage Link. Signature Sale 1913sTypell NGC VF 25

koynekwest

Ridculous! NGC is so highly regarded in general-yet I see crap like this all the time-both circulated and Mint state all the time in NGC slabs. I think it's time collectors get really objective with this over rated slabbing company. (Just an opinion-please-no lawsuits.)

jcping

Well.... it is an NGC coin

TonedCoinTrader

UncleJoe

MAX F-13 1/2

There is serious overgrading in the Buffalo series.

Joe.

UncleJoe

F-13 1/2 MAX!!!

There is serious overgrading in the Buffalao Series.

Bid based on YOUR grade NOT the slab's grade.

Joe.

au58

Official grading service of the PNG.

dorkkarl

you could probably get it upgraded at pcgs.

i mean, cmon, how many times do you have to see horn-less buff's graded xf in pcgs & ngc plastic to realize how screwed up mkt-grading is today?

K S

newport

Since I'm new to collecting, this is actaully the first xtreamly overgraded Buffalo I have seen in a professional slab graded by number 2.

Shamika

I hate to say it, but dorkkarl is right. The same kind of grading for circulated Buffalo's is seen in PCGS slabs.

dorkkarl

let's be blunt. it's a $100 worth of coin, & $200 worth of plastic

don't be a fool, PASS

K S

MacCoin

13S is a key! I don't think you find much better for under $300.00. It list for $255.00 for a G in Mays price guide

IrishMike

<< <i>Since I'm new to collecting, this is actaully the first xtreamly overgraded Buffalo I have seen in a professional slab graded by number 2. >>



When did you see the coin?

newport

It's up for auction now on Heritage Sig. Sale

IrishMike

You missed my point, you said you saw the coin when in actuality you haven't. Coins are graded in person not through photos espcially those from Heritage. I would suggest to you that if you are new to the hobby you should not buy coins sight unseen. You will also see photos of coins in all TPG holder that look graded properly, undergraded as well as overgraded.

haletj

Heritage's scans are fine to grade circ coins from. Sometimes not ms coins.

LAWMAN

That coin hasn't seen VF in a long, long time. Come on.

Cherwood

Hi everyone! This is my first post here. I'm fairly new to coin collecting, but have been reading all your post and trying to learn about grading. I'm really glad I found this site - I'm really learning a lot.

OK......question here. Maybe my eyesight isn't good enough for coin collecting, but I can't even read the date on that coin? What's up with that?

kamehameha00

<< <i>Maybe my eyesight isn't good enough for coin collecting, but I can't even read the date on that coin? What's up with that? >>



There is a zoom-in feuture on the picture.


Looks like a VG-8 at best IMHO.

mgoodm3

Dates wear out quickly on buffalos. I agree with the general consensus about a fine grade.