Grade opinions on my 1895 S Morgan and..

Trooper

Hi all, came in the mail the other day. It was a Ebay BIN with 2 other Morgans( a worn 1892 and a ms63 1885O. Total cost for all three delivered was $60. So I think I didn't do to bad.
Here's a pic of the coin. I was thinking of having it graded because it is a rarer Morgan, and even with the grading fees I don't think I'd lose any money if I wanted to sell. But there's a little hint of green at the bow on the reverse. For a coin in this condition would acetone change the look of the coin if I just q'tipped it on the bow? Or would you do a whole dip. Or just leave it and send it in.
I'm guessing F12 for a grade? Anyone else?
Will the nic on the obv rim keep it out of a holder?
thanks
Tom

Bubblehead

Jeeze, nice wins. Super reasonable, too!
I have had Morgan's BB'd for similar rim dings.
But, maybe because of the scarcity of this one, they will allow some slack...
I'd send it in, if it were mine.

morganbarber

I don't think it could go over VG. I am not familiar enough with grading companies to comment on whether the nick keeps the coin out of a slab. Very good deal on the three.

BAJJERFAN

G6 or vg8

DennisH

Good-6... because the rims and denticles aren't complete on either side.

jdimmick

That coin wont make Good-6, it might g-4, but I am more inclined to say Ag-3.

The coin that PCgs had in round three of the grading challenge had considerable more detail and no wear into the rim. I thought it was a good-6, but they graded G-4.

LincolnCentMan

G4

David

BigAl

looks like a G6 to me, however I'm not so sure it will make it in a slab......is there significant rim damage on the bottom of the reverse (hidden by the keyboard)? If the rims are damaged, pcgs will bag it.

dollardude

Wow, awesome deal! I would grade her G04 details/cleaned/retoned/rim damage/net FR02.