How much would you pay for a hypothetical coins graded by various TPGs?

Aethelred

Lets say there is a coin you want for your collection/inventory. You are willing to pay $1000 for this coin graded MS-64 by your favorite service. How much would you pay for it if graded by:

PCGS
NGC
ANACS
ICG
SEGS
PCI
ACG

Baley

depends on what it's worth in

65
64
64 or 63
64 or 63
63 or 62
62 or 61 or 60 or 58 or 55
62 or 61 or 60 or 58 or 55 or 53 or 50 or 45 or 40 or 35...

Stuart

A good starting point would be to check the Certified Coin Market Indicator on the front page of the Coin Dealer Newsletter (Greysheet).

In the Feb 27th issue they state avg. weekly comparison of certified coin bid levels relative to CDN sigth-seen bid levels (as 100%)...

PCGS.. 83%
NGC.... 83%
ANACS 57%
ICG..... 86%
PCI..... 56%
SEGS.. 56%
NCI......34%
INS..... 32%

This is at least a relative guide to begin the thought process...

JrGMan2004

Disregarding the grade on the label, if I thought it was a 64...

$1000
$1000
$1000
$500
$500
$250
$2...

If it's MS64 on the holder...

$1000
$1000
$1000
$0
$0
$0
$0

nankraut

$1000
$900
$800
$500
$200
$100
They would have to pay me to take it.

dorkkarl

that's a bizarre question. what would the plastic co. have to do w/ it if i'm interested in the coin?

K S

Aethelred

The idea here is to try to gauge how much collcetors value the opinions of the various TPGs.