Let's play grade-the-buff!! (answer given)

BigGreek

Grading MS Buffalos has to be a very demanding task. Below are two 1938D
with similar color but obviously different strikes. They are in different types of
slab but have the same grade. Can you guess that grade. For super bonus:
can you guess the slab.

Coin 1:




Coin 2 (soft reverse is my fault):




The answers are Coin 1 and Coin 2

darktone

BigGreek, don't show the grades right away next time and you might get more resposes. I'll guess MS66 on both and the first one is in an old PCGS rattler and the second one is grade by NTC. mike

BigGreek

<< <i>BigGreek, don't show the grades right away next time and you might get more resposes. I'll guess MS66 on both and the first one is in an old PCGS rattler and the second one is grade by NTC. mike >>



You are amazin'

Now, do you think the first has a shot at 67?

grip

66 and 63,what holder I dont know.
Al

darktone

<< <i>You are amazin' >>

. Really to tell a coin from being a 66 to a 67 from a picture really can't be done but it does look nice. mike