Grade the ACG crackout--I can take it---I hope!!!

DorkGirl

OK guys, here she is, my only crackout. I'll post the ACG grade later. Give me your grade and AGC's. One quick sidebar, it's amazing how all the little dings show up when you blow up a coin this large! I bought her 2 years ago, and while I wasn't a complete fool, I was a rookie.

PutTogether

I'll say AU55

and ACG said............MS64?

Russ

EF45 - AU50 if it has some luster.

Edited to add: No idea what ACG graded it.

Russ, NCNE

davewang202

My WAG is AU50.

millennium

I'll go with ..AU50...ACG was AU58......Looks to have some wear.

mozeppa

acg's grade was ms-63

darktone

XF40

relayer

AU-50 (and probably cleaned ?)

ACG - MS65

RiffRaff1967

Looks AU55 to me. Not sure what ACG graded it - but I'm sure it won't surprise me if it is higher than ms62.

ms71

AU50, maybe 53.

prooflike

AU50, ACG graded it MS64

Robgetty

AU50,
ACG MS65

291fifth

XF40, cleaned.

MICHAELDIXON

XF 40 severely cleaned

mgoodm3

EF40, ACG AU58.

Merc

Circulated and dipped. Flat lifeless luster. Ef40

Hadleydog

EF-45 cleaned, accucrap ms64.

SarasotaFrank

xf-40 in the real world, AGC probably gared it AU-55 or 58

jdimmick

Looks Xf-40 to 45 cleaned,

ACG graded it in the Au-55 range or higher.

Barry

AU-50 cleaned
ACG grade MS64

tsacch

AU53........acg ms63

rainbowroosie

XF 40 cleaned, they said 63

DennisH

AU50 cleaned.

JadeRareCoin

My grade: VF-35
ACG grade: AU-53 (they probably did not use "DMPL" on this one.......)

Bear

VF Cleaned PCGS- AU

KlectorKid

Ill call it net F-12, XF-45.

itsnotjustme

bb for cleaning.

Stuart

XF-45 and likely cleaned -- perhaps net-grading down to VF35/XF40... AccuGrade probably AU-55??

dizzlecc

dizzlecc

XF-45.

You did pick up a rare morgan though which is good is that condition.

MrLee

AU-50

ACG= MS-60.

fcloud

AU50 (looks cleaned)

AGC MS64

K6AZ

Detail wise, looks AU50 but that nasty gouge on the cheek might cause a BB at PCGS or NGC. ACG grade? Who knows, most like MS something.

razorface1027

The wing tips have been spared. The gouge in the face (what appears to be a gouge by the pics), along with the flat devices, no luster, and of course the pics; I'd say XF-45. ACG probably gave it AU-58.

Shamika

That kid has had a bath!

ealandg

Real life - XF40, dipped.
ACG Grade - MS62

DorkGirl

Well, here it is:




I graded it xf and paid strong xf money for it. Not any noticable harsh cleaning, subdued luster, soft light toning. I bought the coin, not the holder-----thanks for all your opinions, I hope you had as much fun with the thread as I did. Becky

K6AZ

Sometimes you get lucky with those coins, and usually they are coins that individuals sent in to be graded. If you buy these sight unseen over the internet, you are asking for trouble.

Aethelred

If I have said onece that I hate to grade from scans, I have said it a thousand times. However, based on what I see I would grade it VF-30.

nankraut

XF details, VF30 cleaned. BIG hit on cheek. ACG probably graded MS63

jcping

BB, Cleaned

joecool

I say XF45......

ACG MS64 DMPL.....

dorkkarl

xf-40 for me. lower if it's cleaned.

K S

JadeRareCoin

Sooooo. DorkKarl is posting to DorkGirl's thread............

Hmmmmmm. Do I hear wedding bells???

kamehameha00

I think we are all being a little harsh on ACG.Even a grading company that usually grades 1-3 points off on each coin would never grade this as a MS64 DMPL as joecool said or a MS something grade as a lot of you other people said.We all know ACG isn't the worst company at grading coins.

kamehameha00