Options
What coin BEST represents America and why?
ccex
Posts: 1,188 ✭✭✭
Last week, before the now-100+ post thread about the worst representation of U.S. coins became unreadable by the apolitical, I posted a response suggesting this thread. My vote for the coin that best represented our nation was the 1936 Bridgeport Commemorative half, but I did not elaborate why.
Another forum member (PutTogether) asked me why this was my choice, and I replied as follows, to his satisfaction.
"I love the Bridgeport commemorative half for many reasons. The most obvious is the celebration of P.T. Barnum on a U.S. Coin. Although Barnum never said "a sucker is born every minute" (-- his competitor, who promoted the Cardiff Giant did) Barnum's name is associated with this phrase. You put it much more diplomatically with "his undying spririt of capitalism"
I am also a fan of P.T. Barnum as an outrageous and famous showman. I doubt if we'll ever see James Brown on a U.S. coin, so Barnum will have to do as "the hardest working man in show business." Barnum's embellishment of the truth is the epitome of the advertising and marketing industries which are largely responsible for today's American roadsides. Gone are the humble mom-and-pop variety stores and cafeterias, replaced by Walmart and Kentucky Fried Chicken.
The congressional authorization for a coin celebrating an anniversary of Bridgeport probably wouldn't happen today. Of course there are U.S. Commemoratives for even less relevant national events: York County, Lynchburg, Ft. Vancouver and many others - even an irrelevant non-event in the case of the 50th anniversary of Cincinnati as a center of music. Still I applaud the idea of a local hero getting national attention and becoming legendary. This is the land of opportunity, after all.
Don't overlook the ultra-modern eagle on the reverse. America is always putting new twists on old ideals. If the Bill of Rights can be interpreted to fit modern practices (freedom of speech in the face of the internet, or gays claiming civil rights), eagles on our coins should also be able to reflect some modern artistic license. I'm glad we have grown past stiff conventional eagles like the ones on the reverses of the Kennedy or Barber halves.
Also, have you ever looked at Henry Kreiss' Bridgeport eagle upside down? It looks like a shark. America can also appear surrealistic to many a first time visitor. "
I hope that this thread will die before 100+ posts expand it to disagreements between forum members as to the policies of particular dead presidents and their legacies. I admit that I am proud to have chosen parents born in the USA. and don't post here as often as most. I also spent 3 years in the Peace Corps in Ghana, travelling around West Aftica listening to opinions of what America means to people in that part of the world. I respect the opinions of others here who can demonstrate that the US mint has produced a coin which better represents the nation than my personal favorite, the Bridgeport/Barnum half. Please try to keep it focused on a coin design.
Another forum member (PutTogether) asked me why this was my choice, and I replied as follows, to his satisfaction.
"I love the Bridgeport commemorative half for many reasons. The most obvious is the celebration of P.T. Barnum on a U.S. Coin. Although Barnum never said "a sucker is born every minute" (-- his competitor, who promoted the Cardiff Giant did) Barnum's name is associated with this phrase. You put it much more diplomatically with "his undying spririt of capitalism"
I am also a fan of P.T. Barnum as an outrageous and famous showman. I doubt if we'll ever see James Brown on a U.S. coin, so Barnum will have to do as "the hardest working man in show business." Barnum's embellishment of the truth is the epitome of the advertising and marketing industries which are largely responsible for today's American roadsides. Gone are the humble mom-and-pop variety stores and cafeterias, replaced by Walmart and Kentucky Fried Chicken.
The congressional authorization for a coin celebrating an anniversary of Bridgeport probably wouldn't happen today. Of course there are U.S. Commemoratives for even less relevant national events: York County, Lynchburg, Ft. Vancouver and many others - even an irrelevant non-event in the case of the 50th anniversary of Cincinnati as a center of music. Still I applaud the idea of a local hero getting national attention and becoming legendary. This is the land of opportunity, after all.
Don't overlook the ultra-modern eagle on the reverse. America is always putting new twists on old ideals. If the Bill of Rights can be interpreted to fit modern practices (freedom of speech in the face of the internet, or gays claiming civil rights), eagles on our coins should also be able to reflect some modern artistic license. I'm glad we have grown past stiff conventional eagles like the ones on the reverses of the Kennedy or Barber halves.
Also, have you ever looked at Henry Kreiss' Bridgeport eagle upside down? It looks like a shark. America can also appear surrealistic to many a first time visitor. "
I hope that this thread will die before 100+ posts expand it to disagreements between forum members as to the policies of particular dead presidents and their legacies. I admit that I am proud to have chosen parents born in the USA. and don't post here as often as most. I also spent 3 years in the Peace Corps in Ghana, travelling around West Aftica listening to opinions of what America means to people in that part of the world. I respect the opinions of others here who can demonstrate that the US mint has produced a coin which better represents the nation than my personal favorite, the Bridgeport/Barnum half. Please try to keep it focused on a coin design.
"Never attribute to malice what can be adequately explained by stupidity" - Hanlon's Razor
0
Comments
The FDR commemorative
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
2 Cam-Slams!
1 Russ POTD!
Too bad they're so damn expensive.
2 Cam-Slams!
1 Russ POTD!
<< <i>The roosevelt dime, because he so accurately represented the American spirit. >>
Hmmm.......some people might take that the wrong way
Thomas Jefferson was the author of the most significant document in world history.
I believe our 5 cent coin is the perfect reflection of what our country was meant to be.
I'm really not arguing against the OP's choice, so much as I am just adding my opinion.
Forbid it, Almighty God!
I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty, or give me death!
~PATRICK HENRY~
<< <i>Last week, before the now-100+ post thread about the worst representation of U.S. coins
It's now 200+ posts.
Glad to see a balance thread to it. Thank you.
I have to agree with the Jefferson Nickel.( I'm changing my original vote for the Fugio)
You're right. He is the author of the worlds most significant document and in my opinion should be honored as such.
Rgrds
TP
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
Classic 100% pure American!!!!!
and throw in a 55 Frankie!
"Senorita HepKitty"
"I want a real cool Kitty from Hepcat City, to stay in step with me" - Bill Carter
TP
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
He was an inventor, and like many Americans, a true capitalist. He didn’t have to steel from others, he simply cashed in on whatever opportunities that came his way. He was the Bill Gates of his time. Unfortunately, he just didn’t have the financial advisors that Bill has today.
He didn’t give a damn about religion, politics, or anything else that interfered with anyone’s personal freedom. To me, Ben was what Liberty is all about. As long as it doesn’t cause anyone physical, emotional or financial grief, do what the hell you want!
Now, granted Ben didn’t always live up to the standards that others thought he should. He spent the many fortunes he earned on dining, wining and brothels in more of the finer locals of both this young nation and abroad. And, had he had those fabulous advisors, he probably wouldn’t have died penniless. Nevertheless, for his time he probably enjoyed more in a few short years than a lot of us hope to in a lifetime, and he not only did it his way, he did it as a free American!
Ben Franklin served this nation well, and he, like many Americans who followed him, served himself to a heaping plateful of what this nation had to offer, and still does to anyone who has the gumption he had.
On the reverse, the Liberty Bell. Need I say more? Bleeding heart liberals and fascists need not answer. This isn’t the Rush Limbaugh show.
I served the United States of America in the US Air Force, and I'm damned proud of it.
Live right, die well, and everyone will celibrate your life and drink hearty at your wake!
Craig
I'd like to submit the Fugio cent and the Continental Currency; the designs are not only timeless, but extremely pregnant with meaning and good advice. I'd love to see such symbolism on coins today. The phrase "To be esteemed, be useful" embodies the capitalist, freedom-oriented mood that this country once had. Also, "time flies" is equally apt.
Too, I find the Walking Liberty Half and Standing Liberty Quarter not only wonderful symbols of America, but unspeakably beautiful as well. The St. Gaudens Double Eagle (for the same reason), and Buffalo Nickel (because of its depiction of uniquely American symbols) are also high on my list.
"Ask, and it shall be given you; seek, and ye shall find; knock, and it shall be opened unto you." -Luke 11:9
"Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God is one LORD: And thou shalt love the LORD thy God with all thine heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy might." -Deut. 6:4-5
"For the LORD is our judge, the LORD is our lawgiver, the LORD is our king; He will save us." -Isaiah 33:22
Lincoln cent;
Franklin half (not the best design, but arguably the best representative of America on U.S. coins);
Walking Liberty half;
St. Gauden's $20 gold.
-Jay
e-mail me here
WINNER:
POTD 8-30-05 (awarded by dthigpen)
POTD 9-8-05 (awarded by gsaguy)
GSAGUY Slam 12-10-04
Total Copper Nutcase - African, British Ships, Channel Islands!!!
'Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons, for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup'
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
<< <i>
<< <i>The roosevelt dime, because he so accurately represented the American spirit. >>
Hmmm.......some people might take that the wrong way
Knee slapper
.
CoinsAreFun Toned Silver Eagle Proof Album
.
Gallery Mint Museum, Ron Landis& Joe Rust, The beginnings of the Golden Dollar
.
More CoinsAreFun Pictorials NGC FOR SALE
Eric
The Oregon Trail Memorial commemorative gets my vote.
If you were to just hand someone a coin and not be able elaborate on why it best describe America, I think this one has a lot going for it.
A Native American, pioneers... and a map to boot!
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
<< <i>"What coin BEST represents America and why?"
The Oregon Trail Memorial commemorative gets my vote.
If you were to just hand someone a coin and not be able elaborate on why it best describe America, I think this one has a lot going for it.
A Native American, pioneers... and a map to boot! >>
That would be my choice as well.
Lance.
<< <i>Really, I like the $20 St. Gaudens double eagle. Walking Liberty on the front a heavy, majestic eagle on the reverse.
Too bad they're so damn expensive. >>
Agreed. America lighting the way for the rest of the world, ready to lead. Confident. Strong. Ready to assert itself on the world stage. And a darn pretty coin to boot!
Mine would be 1793 flowing hair large cent--love the Liberty with the windblown hair. She got tame all too soon.
<< <i>1976 quarter >>
That's my vote too. Washington, the man who would not be king (though he was not a humble man by any stretch) on the obverse. The drummer boy reverse. Most of the revolutionary war drummer boys were too young to do much good in a fight. After some time in the field, almost all the drummer boys had tattered uniforms, perhaps no shoes, perhaps no longer even a drum, only a fife.
<< <i>The buffalo nickle - the only coin that represents two of the icons of true Americana - the indian and the buffalo!!! >>
Absolutely this. All those wonderful men, Lincoln, Franklin, etc came later in America's history.
bob