Response to feedback ??

wufdude · February 27, 2004 5:21AM

Please check my Ebay feedback, "wufdude". A buyer just gave a neutral for a '82 Ripken PSA 7, stating that I did not say it had a crease!! Knowing that PSA would not give a 7 to a card with a crease, what I should I do if the buyer does not retract the comment?

goodriddance189 · February 27, 2004 5:57AM

neutrals dont affect your feedback rating, i believe

Rainman · February 27, 2004 7:50AM

Neutrals don’t impact your rating, but I’d respond w/something like “card was in a PSA 7 holder when shipped and shipped in a bubble envelope” or something else you feels reflects the condition of the card

Remobolan · February 27, 2004 8:37AM

Wufdude,

That is absolute crap. The whole backbone of the grading industry is that if something is a 7 it's a 7. If you buy a graded card and have a problem with the condition take it up with the grading company not the guy who sells it as a 7. There are alot of idiots on ebay and they don't have a clue as to what they are buying. My policy has always been no returns on graded cards and see scan for condition. It sould speak for itself. Tell the guy to get a life and go buy raw from a dealer who will tell him a near mint card is one that looks like my dog chewed on it for a week. Thats my story and I'm sticking to it!

Sorry, I had to get that out, I feel you pain.

pc · February 27, 2004 2:35PM

well i have a problem with your logic.
if a card like the 1966 mccovey psa 10
has a HUGE corner crease that is EASILY
visible in person but not on the scan shouldnt
you mention it or atleast offer a refund given
a high probability the buyer will be unhappy?

wufdude · February 27, 2004 10:37PM

To clarify, I had not knowledge at all of a crease. I had personally sent the card in for grading. It was probably a rough corner, which could still justify a 7, which the buyer didn't like??

felix76 · February 27, 2004 11:22PM

Since it was only a neutral, and not the horrible neg. *shutters*, do what Remobolan said.
Simply reply with something that says " Card was graded a 7 by PSA, you should have known what a 7 was before you purchased it. Did you expect to see a Gem Mint 10 in a 7's case?

I know PSA is not always on the money with some of their grades, but they wouldn't be that far off.

The card could have had a surface wrinkle that was so small it was invisible with the naked eye, but this guy is so anal that he will search it over with a fine tooth comb. He probably bought it to try to turn it back in for a 8 or better. Seen quite a few people do that.

Just my thoughts.

Thanks for letting me express them.

Response to feedback ??

Comments