Sounds like the buyer had a guarantee that the coin would cross. I don't care how nice the coin looks, no one in their right mind (no one who didn't have money to burn, that is) would take that kind of risk.
MY COMMENT FROM THE REGISTRY BOARD THREAD ON THE SAME SUBJECT:
IMHO,
The 1910(s) in PCGS-MS67RD sold under where it would have sold in a Heritage sale (ex: $32k+ for a pop 3 1930(s) cent recently). The coin is easily a $40k+ in this market (true - seller would have only netted around 85% of the Heritage sell price, so he did fine as well). I tried to get a customer of mine to step up to that level, but, it was just bad timing to commit the funds. I tip my hat to the (2) bidders at around $36k each as they had both "balls' and knowledge/skill of the true market for this coin. I am also quite content with the PQ MS66RD of this date I placed in my set for under $3,500 - I LOVE THE UNDERGRADE COINS AT 1/10 THE PRICE!! But, ifI was a player for a top Lincoln set (which luckily I am not), this coin would have been a "must win" for me at under the $40k level.
Wondercoin
Please visit my website at www.wondercoins.com and my ebay auctions under my user name www.wondercoin.com.
<< <i>Sounds like the buyer had a guarantee that the coin would cross. I don't care how nice the coin looks, no one in their right mind (no one who didn't have money to burn, that is) would take that kind of risk. >>
It was already in the PCGS holder when it sold for $36,201. It was purchased by the seller for less than $3k when it was in the ICG holder.
Comments
IMHO,
The 1910(s) in PCGS-MS67RD sold under where it would have sold in a Heritage sale (ex: $32k+ for a pop 3 1930(s) cent recently). The coin is easily a $40k+ in this market (true - seller would have only netted around 85% of the Heritage sell price, so he did fine as well). I tried to get a customer of mine to step up to that level, but, it was just bad timing to commit the funds. I tip my hat to the (2) bidders at around $36k each as they had both "balls' and knowledge/skill of the true market for this coin. I am also quite content with the PQ MS66RD of this date I placed in my set for under $3,500 - I LOVE THE UNDERGRADE COINS AT 1/10 THE PRICE!! But, ifI was a player for a top Lincoln set (which luckily I am not), this coin would have been a "must win" for me at under the $40k level.
Wondercoin
<< <i>Sounds like the buyer had a guarantee that the coin would cross. I don't care how nice the coin looks, no one in their right mind (no one who didn't have money to burn, that is) would take that kind of risk. >>
It was already in the PCGS holder when it sold for $36,201. It was purchased by the seller for less than $3k when it was in the ICG holder.
Russ, NCNE
What a steal!
That would be interesting.
<< <i>Title of thread and first post is extremely misleading >>
Of course. Look who posted it.
Russ, NCNE
Registry 1909-1958 Proof Lincolns
roadrunner