Why do the surfaces look so bad on this pattern (is it real?)

Steve27

LINK

kamehameha00

I wouldn't buy a coin this rare and expensive raw,especially on eBay.

coinguy1

Steve, I believe that is a pattern which is often, if not usually found with a "wood-grain" effect to the color. I think the surfaces are probably ok but that you are seeing the typical, uneven color/toning pattern (no pun intended).

Edited to add: I still wouldn't recommend that someone buy it (or other high priced coins) uncertified, unless there is a full return privilege offered by a well known, reputable seller AND the buyer is expert.

MrEureka

What the CoinGuy said.

tlhoy

It has that Matte Proof look!
Glenn

dorkkarl

it's just woodgrain toning. actually, a very nice coin. i doubt it's fake.

K S

Pushkin

Lakesammman

Emailed the seller when it was first listed - he says the reverse picture is the more representative color of the entire coin.