Grade this Morgan

BigAl

How do you think pcgs would grade this Morgan?






thanks for your input.

legacycoin

The photo makes it look like it's been dipped so no grade from PCGS, detail-wise it looks to be AU50 or so....

relayer

hard to tell, but I'd say AU-55

davewang202

~AU50. cleaned?

K6AZ

No Grade - cleaning

Edited to add: Looks like the PCGS XF that is up on eBay right now. I'm looking for this date in that grade, but it is obviously one that PCGS let get into a slab because of the date.

BigAl

difficult to grade by photo, but I tend to agree with you guys...AU50ish but cleaned.

Hold on to your seats......Linker

this coin must have been circulating in an 'all-gloved' community back in the good ole days.

BigAl

good eye K6. I'm also looking for a 95-o to replace the one usps lost on the 7th.

When I clicked on the link, 'PCGS 1895-O XF45'.....this was the last thing i expected to see. honestly thought it was a hoax at first.

K6AZ

PCGS does this on a handful of dates, the 79-CC, 89-CC, 93-O, 93-S, 94, 95-O and 95-S. They will slab coins they would body bag if they were any other date. In this case, we are looking at a polished AU coin that PCGS has "net graded" to XF 45. This is a disgrace and ought to be an embarassment to PCGS. It's also why I will not buy the few remaining dates I need sight unseen, I want a problem free coin, not one that has been net graded in the blind.

razorface1027

This is a disgrace and ought to be an embarassment to PCGS. It's also why I will not buy the few remaining dates I need sight unseen, I want a problem free coin, not one that has been net graded in the blind

I couldn't agree more!...If I wanted a net graded coin, which, by the way, I don't...I'd send it or buy a ANACS specimen. If PCGS starts doing like anacs,...."There goes the neighborhood."