Has anyone seen those new NGC holders for state quarters?

Rampage

This may have already been touched upon, but I was on the website and saw this slab below. I was planning on joining their club and found out this came free with each sign-up.

Reason for joining NGC is because I like the way their holders look with certain coins. Just like I like the way PCGS holders look for most everything else. Anyway.....here is the slab:


Anyone ever see it? What do you think about it? Good idea? Bad idea? I kind of like it. But, how to be sure that every coin is as the grade states? Do they average the grades?

relayer

I have a buyer at $24.99 with 4 days to go

The PCGS premium (2003 Eagle) only sold for $10.19, so I like the NGC quarter set

wingedliberty

I don't like the idea of blanket grading. I think individual grades should be assigned to each coin. The holders are nice though.

flaminio

<< <i>I don't like the idea of blanket grading. >>



Why not? If all five coins are indeed MS65s, what's the difference of just writing one "MS65" vs. "MS65 MS65 MS65 MS65 MS65"?

That said, I'm not a big fan of the multiholders from either NGC or PCGS.

Louis

I saw the NGC multi holder at The Houston Money Show with individual grades listed that were different, so maybe they list them individually only if they are different.

wingedliberty

What are the chances of all five coins being 65., or is NGC just savings time and money?

flaminio

<< <i>What are the chances of all five coins being 65., or is NGC just savings time and money? >>



I don't think it's ever been stated or implied that all five came from the same mint set. It seems perfectly reasonable to me that NGC picked out five coins because they were all the same grade. Chance had nothing to do with it.

wingedliberty

I mean if I am a submitter. What are the chances?

tradedollarnut

I believe that NGC is only accepting already graded coins for their multicoin holder - therefore, since it's a requirement, the chance that all 5 are the same grade is pretty darn good!

supracoin

nice holder, just too big in my opinion. great concept though.

JMOORE

PutTogether

I have one of those, just got it in the mail the other day.

Dabigkahuna

PCGS has these type holders also. I inquired about them and was told that they are available on bulk submissions only! 100 coins or more of each date, mm and denomination. You have to submit, in the case of the quarters, at least 500 coins and then the top matching grades are put in the holders. They are graded first. Im told, prior to going into the holder.

I don't know what NGC requires but they are nice looking for sure!

Larry
Dabigkahuna

Cladiator

I don't like the look or size of them. Just my opinion

Conder101

The multi-coin holder first came out at the end of July 2003 and have been through at least three production varieties plus one novelty variety since then.

Eventually NGC plans on issuing multi-coin holders with each coin graded but at first they would only accept matching grade, previously graded NGC slabbed coins for re-holdering into the new multi-coin holder at a cost of $8 per coin unless the coins are 70's. In that case the re-holdering cost was $40 per coin. I very strongly suspect though that they also let some major submitters send in huge numbers of proof sets and then built matching sets for them from the proof sets (even though supposedly that wasn't possible yet).

pontiacinf

I need a 2002 proof set slabbed like this...anyone have one for sale?

Conder101

You might check silvertowne they had runs of both clad and slver proofs 99 - 03 awhile back. I don't know if they still do.