Toning experts**Are These Toned Peace Dollars** Newspaper Toned... Album Toned... Or AT???

stman

What you think? Yes I own them as well And Peaceman, I know they are common dates.

Russ

Newspaper toned? Is that a real category?

Russ, NCNE

stman

<< <i> hate to say it but I think all 4 are AT. >>



Reasons?

airplanenut

I'd say they're album toned... I've seen quite a few denominations that produce those patterns with album toning... here's an example from a nickel set of mine:

stman

MANOFCOINS.... I have no problem with your opinion. I think it makes for better discussion to explain an opinion sometimes.

lablover

stman,
You know what I'll say...no way their AT, considering who you bought them from. And, I'm still mad you got that 1924 before I did COOL COLORS!!!! Still, would have looked great with this one I own...

wallstreetman

I will have to agree with MANOCOINS, for the reason he mentioned. Dip em in Acetone, if the toning doesnt come off, then who cares if theyre AT! The artists need to start putting theyre signature on em!

stman

<< <i>stman,
You know what I'll say...no way their AT, considering who you bought them from. And, I'm still mad you got that 1924 before I did COOL COLORS!!!! >>



Haha... actually the one you said you're mad about I didn't buy that one. All of these have come from different sellers though.

lablover

<< <i>Haha... actually the one you said you're mad about I didn't buy that one >>



What, it's still available? Quick, where's his number. Still, I like em all...and their NT...IMHO.

Baley

hmmm, another 1924. Must have been one hell of a roll!

stman

<< <i>I will have to agree with MANOCOINS, for the reason he mentioned. Dip em in Acetone, if the toning doesnt come off, then who cares if they're AT! The artists need to start putting theyre signature on em! >>



But But WSM.... what if they are in your favorite grading company's holder that you always say are the best?

rainbowroosie

The bottom three are album toned nice coins; maybe the pic is lousy, but the first coin looks AT?????

wallstreetman

Like I said, I have no problem with AT thats there to stay!

wallstreetman

But it cant be as dull as the top coin either!

Outhaul

I don't think any are AT. I've seen this type of toning on Peace dollars before, rarely, but I've seen it just the same. Album toned for sure. Beautiful coins.

Cheers,

Bob

stman

<< <i>But it cant be as dull as the top coin either! >>



I agree that coin is DULL. That one happens to be in the grading service holder that you are always saying can do no wrong.

wallstreetman

Whats the grade? Or would you rather me guess?

stman

I guess I should have said in the title these were on ebay to get more opinions?

stman

Dog97

<<<maybe the pic is lousy, but the first coin looks AT>>>
That picture is from the bestest picture taker on this board & eBay I think. Least I think, I think I recognize that auction from a while back.
I thought that was the best looking coin & picture stman.
Yeah I think they toned that way from reading the newspaper. heehe

Peaceman

I made another $ 1.00.... WOO HOO!!!!