Do you guys think this Mantle would cross to a PSA 9?!?

Davino

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=2773419937&category=55922#ebayphotohosting


Another "great" PRO card. Do they have a grade below Mint? What a sham...

spacktrack

Mantle

I'm going to go with NO for the crossing question.

And, believe it or not, I think I have seen PRO 5.5 cards!

jimrupprecht

If you're contemplating a bid, at least make sure the seller will send you ALL the pieces of the card, not just the one that made it in the holder.

-
JR

Davino

<< <i>If you're contemplating a bid, at least make sure the seller will send you ALL the pieces of the card, not just the one that made it in the holder.

-
JR >>



THAT is the key! We must have the whole card in order to bid, no?

Rainman

i don't think i've seen a pro card graded less than a 9 or 10. funny since most of their "mint" cards look a tad shorter than those in other holders. if i were going to try and cross a card over, i'd go w/sgc first since people seem to have had decent luck w/that and since sgc doesn't (from the limited samples i've seen- i only collect bgs/psa graded cards) seem to have the "shortness" issue that pro does.

pc

Rainman-
"not on Monday, definitely not on Monday."

marty

This card should cross over to a PSA Authentic Trimmed. The winner has only a 2 feedback and the other bidders buy cards graded by fly by night services. The winner could be a shill.

Mantlefan

$131 for a worthless card. Not bad.

NickM

I've seen a PRO 4. It was a '48 Leaf Cliff Aberson (I forget which sleeve variation). The front looked nice. The back had some kid's initials in dark pencil. I guess there are some things even PRO won't overlook.

Nick

Davino

<< <i> I guess there are some things even PRO won't overlook.

Nick >>



Thats a new one to me, I'm surprised that the person that submitted the card didn't just trim it till it looked good.

NickM

Davino - they were large and not near an edge.

Nick