Yea or nay?

ajaan

1804 Dollar

trozau

The rim ding at 3:30 on the reverse is distracting. MOO

cacheman

IMHO it isn't XF...it looks cleaned and dipped to me, has a weak strike, and a number of rim dings...it's up to you. I could way off base too....

ajaan

Thanks, nay it is.

ajaan

How about this one? I assume the color is from the photo and it isn't really copper.

cacheman

Certainly more original and nicer looking. Too bad the photos aren't better, I'd like to have a closer look at that scratch on George's tunic...

Lloyd

Don
The second one in the UK is looking pretty worn... poor pics but it takes a fair bit to get the shield to really show wear on these...

Lloyd

Askari

I agree with Lloyd ... the 2nd one's gEF days are long past.

Lloyd

The second one is nearer VF or Fine, somewhere between - with that much wear on the shield, and the bad pics, I'm convinced the buyer would be really disappointed...

The first one is a way higher grade but not that attractive - if these coins are not cheap then they have to really look nice IMHO.

L

spinaker2000

Hold out for the copper proof issue Don, then I can buy it from you.

coinkat

keep looking...

Bruce

OH well, both analyzed by the time I got here.

lordmarcovan

I'm with coinkat- keep lookin'. While neither of those is totally nasty, they both leave something to be desired. The second one would have been OK with me but for the long hairline Cacheman pointed out. Looks like a nasty staple scratch.

cosmicdebris

newbiecollector

The first one looks to have been on a pendant/necklace type of attachment (3 o'clock)

Keep looking I say

Aethelred

I like the first one better than the second, but I would not buy either one.

1957joe

nay

Lloyd

7 HOURS to go and the bidding is out of hand @ £122...

I must again draw everyone's attention to the wear on this coin. Look at the King's eyebrow and his profile.!!!!

Repeat - somewhere between Fine and VF....

Lloyd