1884-CC Morgans (PCI & PCGS) on Ebay

pandaman

Not an ad but just wondering how both coins would do on ebay, if I listed them at the same time? See attached scan. FYI---Both graded MS63.

airplanenut

The pics are very small, but I guarantee the PCGS does better

pandaman

I agree. PCGS seems to bring 20-25% higher price. The PCI coin in this case actually little better overall but PCGS should bring more. Will try next week.

pandaman

Experiment will end today. PCI Morgan is hanging in there!! Actually PCI coin is just shade nicer.

Morgans

DCAMFranklin

A pretty cool "experiment/test case"!

pandaman

Well the 1884-CC sales are over. The PCGS brought $140 & the PCI brought $124. Both had about 60 viewers & got 14 & 11 bids respectively. About what expected & with lower submission fees PCI came out better & it really was nicer coin.